Random Notes on Dramatic Space
Dramatic space is a multi-faceted term. Ludwig Wittgenstein applied
a spatial-temporal aspect of "language-games" to Linguistics, while Rudolf
Laban, a developer of a pioneering dance notation called Labanotation,
talked about Space Harmony in concordance with Choreutics, Eukinetics and
ballet. Dramatic space, according to Laban, is established by an
equilibrium between the orientation of the dancer’s body to the orientation
of a surface. In other words, dramatic space is an interaction between
all the participants of a performance; at the same time it’s a relationship
of these participants to their ambiance, whether that ambiance is represented
by nature or by physical man-made structures.
It is interesting to note that Wittgenstein and Laban, both immigrants,
both writing in German, randomly taken by me out of the pile of books,
covered with violet dust, experimented with games. Wittgenstein’s
widely acclaimed and notorious language-games can be compared to Laban’s
"Raumspielpuzzle" (space-game-puzzles). While not completely familiar
with Wittgenstein’s games, I can assume that both language-games and space-game-puzzles
do, to some extent, involve probability. To make a reader more familiar
with Laban’s space-game-puzzles, I cite here a quote from the book by Vera
Maletic The Development of Rudolf Laban’s Movement and Dance Concepts*:
in a space-game-puzzle, "one can either assemble the cards containing directional
symbols according to the rules of spatial games based on Laban’s space
harmony laws or one can draw them by chance arriving at unpredictable sequences."
The concept of randomness is used in painting, music, literature, and dance.
It can be called a helpful tool in creating a dramatic space. In
painting, dramatic space can be built by an artist who faces a painting
from a certain distance and throws paint and/or other objects onto a canvas.
Jackson Pollack’s paintings were created on a floor which became the stage
on which his actions were recorded. In this case, dramatic space
is present not only on a flat surface, within the objects, shapes and colors
of a painting itself, but also between an artist and his/her creation.
The constituents of dramatic space might be the distance from a canvas
to a painter, a rage of a painter and passivity or silent forcefulness
of a painting. Discussing randomness in music, I can mention the
composer John Cage, an author of 4’33" and a performer of Erik Satie’s
18 hours long "Vexations" (Satie’s "Parade" will be discussed few paragraphs
later), who employed the I Ching for composing. As Vera Maletic states,
"charts referring to musical tempi, duration, sounds, and dynamics would
be manipulated in various ways resulting in compositions by chance." (142)
Dramatic space exists not only in art and theatre but also in music.
An effect of dramatization can be created by an assemblage of tempi (of
a monologue or a song), direction/s of a musical phrase (or of a movement
of ballet dancers), silence, and a stable or unstable position of notes
(or of supporting actors) toward a tonality (or toward a theme of a play
or toward main actors. The elements of dramatic space are universal
for all the disciplines: besides the already mentioned directions
of movement, they include the surrounding and supporting structures such
as chords and rhythm in music, walls and placement of participants toward
each other in the theatre, and a juxtaposition of an artist/creator and
art.
Dramatic space exists outside the artist but can also be found within.
Contrary to a kinship of an artist to an outward world (e.g., of a ballet
dancer to an audience), there is a dramatic space inside a creator.
"In a mysterious, puzzling, and mystical way, the true work of art arises
‘from out of the artist.’ Once released from him, it assumes its
own independent life...It is not, therefore, an indifferent phenomenon
arising from chance, living out an indifferent spiritual life, but rather
possesses... further creative, active spaces."* An artist experiences
the dramatic space within him/herself, between an embryo of his/her work
and his/her persona. Also, an artist creates a dramatic space outside
of his/her physical body, between his/her work and him/herself. In
his/her turn (what gender is creation?) a work of art, according to Kandinsky,
"plays a part in the creation of the spiritual atmosphere," possibly creating
dramatic space between itself and other creations that hang around in the
same museum, or a train station, or a museum of train stations.
Dramatic space has to do with architecture and geometry. For example,
in the ballet "Parade" dramatic space was intensified by cubist costumes
designed by Picasso: some dancers were wearing three-dimensional structures
representing skyscrapers made of cardboard. Parades themselves contributed
to a dramatization of space. Usually in France parades were the means
to attract the audience to a theater performance: before the "real"
performance, there was a "preliminary" performance, a parade. The
show tent was separated from the audience by a curtain or a fence, and
in front of these obstructions there was another theatre, another dramatic
space, a parade. In this way, dramatic space was created not only
within the "real" theatre but also between the "real" theatre and an "artificial"
one, between "real" art and its reflection.
In conclusion, I can say that composition can’t exist without dramatic
space. Without framing and referencing the work of art, one can’t
compose. Dramatic space is a multi-layered structure whose radiant
carcass is mutually permeable by artist and his/her art. Dramatic
space is where a stage is. In music, painting and dance dramatic
space is where we create it; it’s where we are.