Running
head: Final Draft
Ready to Rumble?:
Why Women Watch Professional
Wrestling.
Amanda Burns
Saint Mary’s College
Notre Dame, IN
December 1, 2000
Copyright © 2001. Amanda J.
Burns. All Rights Reserved.
Abstract
There are
many theories about why women watch professional wrestling, yet many of them
have never been tested. A qualitative
study was conducted to better understand why women watch professional
wrestling. Nine women who are avid
watchers were interviewed and answered 26 open-ended questions. An analysis of the current research data and
questionnaire responses identified four specific areas as contributing factors
of professional wrestling interest.
These findings indicate that there is a shift in theory regarding women
as wrestling fans.
Ready to Rumble?:
Why Women Watch Professional
Wrestling.
LIGHTS,
cue music, cue effects, CAMERA, cue wrestlers, ACTION. This is just a typical start to any airing
of a professional wrestling televised event.
Avid wrestling fans have tuned in to watch their favorite wrestlers
battle their on going nemeses. Men,
women, boys and girls of all ages have turned out for the event, all claiming
that their favorite wrestler is the best, the meanest, and the strongest there
is.
Everyone
who watches the event reacts and interacts in their own ways to the soap opera
like story lines. Some are deeply
involved and enthraled with a character, while others just sit back and watch
in amazement with the wrestlers actions.
With action not always taking place inside the ring, the question of the
quantity of violence, and how its audience has sometimes reacted, has been
raised. So why do people continue to
watch? Dive into the dark corners of
the ring and find out who still stands once the bell has been rung.
In this corner...Professional Wrestling
Today’s
professional wrestling roots stem from the ‘old world’ wrestling styles of the
Greco-Roman era. It wasn’t until the
mid 1700's that America got its first feel of wrestling. German and Irish immigrants gave wrestling a
‘new world’ twist and staged bouts at country fairs or touring carnivals. “‘At Shows’ (short for athletic shows),
where wrestlers with colorful costumes, equally colorful nicknames, and
fictionalized biographies would wrestle each other or accept challenges from
all local comers.” (Albano, Sugar & Woodson, 1999, p. 16) This new form of wrestling had a stimulating
effect on early America; it brought a new form of entertainment to the
masses. Six United States Presidents
even knocked gloves a few times in the wrestling ring: Washington, Lincoln, T.
Roosevelt, Taylor, Taft, and Coolidge (Albano, Sugar & Woodson, 1999).
The
earliest recorded ‘new world’ wrestling match was in 1871 in Pennsylvania, a
match for “the championship of the United States and Canada and $2,000.” By the 1880's, Greco-Roman wrestling was all
the rage. Greco-Roman wrestling, a
style that was developed in Europe in the 1860's and made its way to America
about 10 years later. This Greco-Roman
style of the time had little similarity to that of the classic Greco-Roman
style, but still persists today in a modified form as an Olympic sport (Albano,
Sugar & Woodson, 1999).
Most of
the first great American wrestlers were made up of first-generation Americans
of European descent. They combined
Greco-Roman wrestling and catch-as-catch-can wrestling. This type of wrestling allowed the wrestlers
to grasp any part of their opponent’s body, and falls were scored whenever both
shoulders of a wrestler touched the floor at the same time. The second wave of American wrestlers, Frank
Gotch, Tom Jenkins, Dan McLeod, and George Hackenschmidt “The Russian Lion,”
used this style and gained audiences and support for the sport of wrestling
(Investigative Reports, 1998).
The
popularity of wrestling to its audience wouldn’t be there if it weren’t for its
superstars. Ed “Strangler” Lewis, was
just that, a superstar of wrestling in the 1920's. In a career of more than 6,200 matches he was to “lose” only 33
times. Gotch and Hackenschmidt would
put on two of the most celebrated bouts in wrestling history and two of the
most controversial. These matches
skyrocketed them into wrestling’s ring of superstars. During the 1920's a promoter, Toots Mondt, wanting to change the
pace of wrestling matches and bring new faces to a growing list of superstars,
decided to install a time limit.
Without the time limit some matches lasted hours and sometimes
days. Mondt also introduced the flying
dropkick, to make matches more interesting to the audiences of the 1920's
(Investigative Reports, 1998).
By the
time the roaring 20's were replaced by the troubled 30's, the American Dream
had become a nightmare. Like all other
forms of entertainment, wrestling struggled for its existence, but fought
on. With wrestlers like Dick Shikat,
Jim Londons, Jim Browning, and Gus Sonnenberg, wrestling continued to
flourish. It was during this time that
promoters decided to shake things up to increase its audiences. They put a time limit of 10-15 minutes on
the matches, started to have women’s wrestling, tag teams, and even mud
wrestling. Crowds finally started
coming back to the ring. “A record 45,000 people paid an estimated $75,000 to
see the July 1933 championship match between Danno O’Mahoney and Ed Don
George.” (Ball, 1990, p. 43) One of the biggest things that the promoters came
up with during the 30's, was to recruit a new kind of wrestler, the former
collegiate football star. Football
stars from the likes of Dartmouth, the University of Nebraska, Notre Dame,
Tennessee, and Minnesota all tried their hands at wrestling. Wrestling’s fortunes didn’t improve
throughout World War II either, times were tough and as with everything,
wrestling suffered. Times were about to
change in a very big way for wrestling and for the rest of the world with the
introduction of the television (Albano, Sugar & Woodson, 1999;
Investigative Reports, 1998).
Television
and professional wrestling were made for each other. It offered an almost made-for-television format and offered
wrestling an entirely new group of fans and fans-to-be. But the professional wrestling era during
the 40's and 50's wouldn’t have been what it was, if it wasn’t for the unique
and standout, Gorgeous George. Gorgeous
George always put on a show and incidentally became wrestling’s first pure
‘performer’, which set the stage for wrestling’s new direction: showbiz. The postwar era for professional wrestling
saw a whole new dimension of action and adventure. With showbiz came athletes from around the world ready to bring
back the bright lights and screaming fans to the professional wrestling arena
of the 60's and 70's. Some of the men
who skyrocketed to the top during this time were Bruno Sammartino, Verne Gagne,
Dick the Bruiser and the von Erich family.
In 1963, one man was about to make a huge change to wrestling and his
name was Vince McMahon Sr. McMahon
broke away from the National Wrestling Alliance (NWA) to form the now famous
WWF. It is with the formation of the
WWF by McMahon with help from his son, Vince McMahon Jr., and later its
competition, World Championship Wrestling (WCW) run by Ted Turner, that
professional wrestling became part of the 1980's pop culture (Albano, Sugar
& Woodson, 1999).
The 1980's
and 90's brought stars like Hulk Hogan, Ric Flair, Stone Cold Steve Austin,
Mankind, The Rock, Goldberg, Sting, The Big Show, Chyna, Sable and Lex Luger
who blew the roof off of wrestling in just a short amount of time and still
continue to dominate today. These are
the current stars and have taken wrestling and made it the blowout success that
reaches 14 million viewers a week and have even conquered the information
superhighway by spawning websites upon websites. Both the WCW and WWF have official websites to find the latest
information on current wrestlers and upcoming events (Albano, Sugar &
Woodson, 1999).
Professional
wrestling, according to Morton and O’Brien (1985), has become a staple in
American culture and in part a ritual in the lives of Americans who watch. “Professional wrestling, too, is more a
drama than a sport. The actors are
athletes, but is ultimately not their athletic prowess that is significant, but
rather their dramatic talents are what makes them success. But just as all drama is not ritual, this
fact alone does qualify professional wrestling as a ritual” (Morton &
O’Brien, 1985, p. 156). This is just
one of the many reasons one might get the itching to watch professional
wrestling. The professional wrestling
performance combines breathtaking athleticism and prodigious showmanship. Wrestlers present themselves as larger than
life figures, wear costumes, have entrances to flashy music, carry trademark
props, and have signature gestures and shouts.
With a soap opera like appearances, professional wrestling provides
mini-plays or dramas that are significant to spectators. The actual competition is secondary in
importance to the drama that precedes and follows each event. According to Rickard, professional
wrestling is the only sport that gives
such an externalized image of torture (Ball, 1990; Mazer, 1998; Morton &
O’Brien, 1985; Rickard, 1999).
In this corner...The Fan
What would
wrestling be without the fans? Millions
of people are tuning into the events on cable television and millions more
going to see the live events all over the United States. With magazines, videos, websites, T-shirts,
action figures, cologne and most recently movies, one cannot go anywhere
without having the force of professional wrestling in their face. At the American University in Washington,
D.C., students have even formed their own club, The American Wrestling Association,
and tune into every wrestling event (Kleiner, 1999).
The fan of
professional wrestling cannot be typecasted into one category. Everyone watches male and female, young and
old, doctors, lawyers, teachers, factory workers, sales people and everyone in
between. Just in the last half of the
1990's professional wrestling has gained increase popularity in American and
has become mainstream. McHugh (1999)
mentions wrestling has always been the area that has generated the dollars and
brought the fans along with it. It was
Gorgeous George in the 50's, Hulk Hogan in the 80's and Goldberg in the 90's,
that brought them coming back time and time again (Economist, 1999; Jensen,
1998; McHugh, 1999; Rossellini, 1999).
With
wrestling fans tuning into wrestling programs however they can. Some fans are intensely involved with the
sport whether playing or as the spectator, which has been labeled as the ‘deep
play’ a term used by Real (1996), or ‘a deep fan’ used by Schrader, Wann and
Wilson (1999). The concept of Deep Play
was developed by Clifford Geertz. “The
theory of deep play in his descriptions of the involvement of Balinese
spectators in the popular ritual cockfight...the involvement of the sports fan
in a mediated sporting even closely parallels this deep play” (Real, 1996, p.
51).
According
to Ball (1990) there have been many theories concerning the popularity of
wrestling as a spectator sport among women, a few of them involve the ‘deep
fan’ approach. The Sport Fan Motivation
Scale (SFMS) is an instrument designed to measure eight different motives of a
sports fan. Written by Scharder, Wann
and Wilson (1999), the eight different motives of a sports fan are eustress,
self-esteem, escape, entertainment, economic, aesthetic, group affiliation, and
family. These eight motives along with
the theories that Ball expresses gives us an insight on how and with what level
of intensity fans, in Ball’s case women and the sport of professional
wrestling, get involved with the sport they watch (Ball, 1990; Wann, 1995;
Schrader, Wann & Wilson, 1999).
In this corner...The Media
With
professional wrestling becoming more and more readily available in the
households of America, and around the world, questions about the level of
violence being portrayed and the amount of violence people watch has been
raised. Holmstrom (1998) writes about
the obscene culture surrounding the world of professional wrestling and its
influences on children. “Much of
today’s wrestling presented by the World Wrestling Federation (WWF) and the
World Championship Wrestling (WCW) has a newfound emphasis on hostility,
obscenities, and sexual explicitness” (Holmstrom, 1998, p. 1).
Berger
(1996) and Brants, Hermes and Zoonan (1998) all agree on the potential
influence on the viewer and take into account the public’s interest of how much
violence the viewer actually watches.
McBrien (1999) probes into the possibility of teaching media literacy to
everyone in the United States. The kind
of viewer that professional wrestling is aimed at are young males between the
age of 16 - 25, but not restricted to them.
Women are also tuning in and are exposed to the same level of intense
violent acts.
Even with
the speculation of the violence in professional wrestling, the soap opera like
story lines, the extreme acrobat like moves, the lights, the music, the
websites, the T-shirts, the money, the flash and pizzaz of the wrestling
personalities, people still tune in and keep coming back. Why is this? Why do people, especially women, watch this form of sports
entertainment? What keeps them coming
back for more? To find out, you will
just have to tune in next time. Are you
ready to rumble?
Purpose and Rationale
Professional
wrestling has become a staple in American culture. Everywhere people turn they are bombarded with T-shirts,
magazines, commercials, televised events, movies and music all inspired by
professional wrestling. Professional
wrestling and television go hand in hand, each playing on the other’s
benefits.
With
millions tuning in all over the world, pro-wrestling wouldn’t be where it is if
it weren’t for the fans. Professional
wrestling, has gone through some up in downs in its life time, but in the last
few years has grown into a multi-billion dollar enterprise. Nothing can stop the force, good or bad,
that professional wrestling has on America and on the world. All though professional wrestling has always
been geared toward male viewers, recently more females have begun to watch and
have jumped onto the pro-wrestling bandwagon.
Many
theories concerning the popularity of wrestling as a spectator sport among
women have been made. None of which
have been scientifically tested and only a few scientifically measured. These theories should be tested. The fact that they haven’t been tested, is
reason enough to do so. This research
will try and put some of these theories to the test by examining “Why women
watch professional wrestling?”
Method
To find
out why women tune in and watch professional wrestling, the method that was
used in this study was a type of qualitative research. Qualitative research was the best way to
conduct this study because, qualitative research is oriented toward the
‘experience,’ the understanding of human activity.
The audio
taped one-on-one interviews were to help the researcher to understand the interviewee’s
activity of watching professional wrestling.
This was done by asking them some open ended questions. The researcher attempted to understand why
they tuned into this male dominated form of sports entertainment by asking the
interviewee 26 open-ended questions.
Sample
The target
population is females that are avid professional wrestling fans. With the impossible feat of trying to
contact every professional wrestling fan that is female around the world, the
only accessible population were females who are avid professional wrestling
fans within the chosen college community.
The
college that was selected for this study, is one of the Nation’s Premier
Catholic Women’s College in the Midwest.
The college insists on a liberal arts foundation for all its
students. A broad-based course of study
invites students to think critically and creatively about the natural world and
human culture. The women, from the
college community that were used in this study are between the ages of 18 and
22 and were in the top 10% of their high school graduation class.
The type
of sample that was collected is purposive.
The reason for collecting a purposive sample is to collect people that
are wrestling fans. Using a random
sample would get a mix of fans and non fans. Purposive sampling allowed the researcher to collect information
from only the female fans.
For the researcher to find all possible
female wrestling fans at the selected college, contacts were made with a few
students who are fans on campus and in a chain-reaction or snowball effect were
put in touch with others. The
researcher had been put into contact with 9 avid wrestling fans. It is also possible the interviewees could
put the researcher in touch with others that watch after the initial interview
with them. The researcher was put into
contact with 3 people in this manner.
This purposive sample allowed the researcher to sample as many
professional wrestling female fans that they can get into contact with at the
selected college as possible.
Instrumentation
The
instrument used in this research was a researcher instrument. For the extended interviews, the interview
schedule consisted of 26 open-ended questions broken up into four sections
(Appendix B and Appendix C). The
extended interview took no longer than an 30-60 minutes to complete by the
interviewee and was audio taped for transcription purposes. The tapes, after the transcription process,
were erased.
The
purpose of the first section of interview questions was to establish basic
background information of the interviewee.
Such as:Age?
Where
are you from?
What
is your major?
The second set of questions deal with the actual
process of watching professional wrestling.
These questions allowed the researcher to find out exactly what the
interviewee is watching and why they watch.
Some questions that are included are as follow:
Do
you watch WWF, WCW, ECW, other, or a combination?
How
often do you watch professional wrestling?
What
motivates you to watch professional wrestling?
At
what age did you start watching professional wrestling?
The third section of the interview schedule tried to
find out what the interviewee gets out of watching professional wrestling. The open-ended questions in this section
allowed the interviewee to express the influences that professional wrestling
has on them. This section consists of
questions like:
Do
you ever reenact/recreate parts of the show?
Do
you have a favorite professional wrestler, and why do you identify with them?
Do
you use any professional wrestling language in your daily life?
Have
you ever attended a live professional wrestling event?
The forth and final section allowed the interviewees
to discuss the issues involving the female professional wrestling fan. This section included questions to start
them talking about the portrayals of women during the wrestling events. It also got them discussing their take on
some of the theories on why women watch professional wrestling. Some of the questions that were asked are:
What
do you think are the reasons why professional wrestling is
appealing to its female viewers?
What
do you think about the way women are portrayed in professional wrestling?
How
do you think women should be portrayed?
If
you could change anything about professional wrestling, what would you change and why?
What
do you think are the differences between professional wrestling’s attractiveness toward
its male viewers and it’s female
viewers?
It is with these 26 questions for the extended
interviews that the researcher had been able to understand what makes
professional wrestling appealing to the female fan, the theory behind why they
watch and how deeply professional wrestling plays a part in their lives.
Procedure
To carry
out this qualitative research extended interviews were performed. There were no risks to the researcher or the
students who participated in this study.
Participants signed a consent form, which was stored separately from the
tapes.
The
researcher set up meeting times with each of the interviewees that was at a
convenient time for both. The
researcher had the interviewee read and sign the consent form before proceeding
with the study. The researcher then
turned on the tape recorder and started to read through the interview questions. The interview lasted between 30 minutes and
an hour depending on the length of the interviewee’s answers to the 26
open-ended questions. At the end of the
interview sessions the tape recorder was turned off.
At this
point the interview was completed and the interviewee was free to leave. The researcher then transcribed the answers
onto paper from the recordings. The
tapes were erased after the transcription process was completed. The written transcripts of the nine
interviews totaled 29 single spaced pages.
The
process of open coding was used to find out the concepts behind, why women
watch professional wrestling. Open coding as described by Corbin and Strass
(1990) is, “the part of analysis that pertains specifically to the naming and
categorizing of phenomena through close examination of data.” (p. 62) The data that was collected in the
interviews was broken down and closely examined using this coding method. A variable list was made to help code the
interviewees answers (Appendix E).
Findings
Participants ranged in ages from 18-22. With the majority, four out of the nine,
being 21 years of age. Three of the
women interviewed hailed from the state of Indiana, as did three from Michigan,
two from Illinois and one from Texas.
There was a wide range of the majors, which seems to indicate that
professional wrestling appeals to people with diverse professional
aspirations. The interviewees majors included
Sociology, Philosophy, Music, Nursing, Art, Psychology, Communications, French
and English Literature and History.
Old Theories
The nine
interviewees gave some insightful answers when they were read four theories
concerning the popularity of wrestling as a spectator sport among women. The first theory states that women are the
‘traditional custodians of morality,’ and are especially attracted to the
morality play between the forces of good and evil (Appendix C). Only two of the women said that it was very
true.
According
to Participant C:
I think that is true. Because women always, well most of the time, want to see the evil people win. It is not always about the good guy winning. Sometimes they want to, they find it exciting to watch the evil person, and cheer for the underdog.
The rest thought the theory was partially true and said that they never really thought about wrestling in that way. Participant F thought the theory was going a ‘little too deep’ and thought wrestlers have both good and evil sides to them. Participant E stated, ‘They are fighting anyway, like is there an ultimate good here?’
With most of these women having not ever thought about the play of good and evil in wrestling, Participant F and E’s statement seems to be the majority. Wrestlers have both good and evil sides to them. They are constantly going back and forth being from the good guy to the bad guy and visa versa. This theory doesn’t seem to have all that much truth to it, after hearing the nine women comment on it. Women don’t seem that good versus evil is what attracts them to watch.
The second theory that was discussed states that girls are socialized to control their hostility and to ‘act like ladies.’ Wrestling acts as a kind of catharsis, allowing them to vent their frustration and their aggressive feelings (Appendix C). Again only three of the women thought this theory rang totally true for them.
Participant
A had this to say:
I can identify with this one. I was raised and a southern belle. Always acting like a lady and was constantly told not to act like a dude. Watching wrestling twice a week gives me an escape. I can understand why there is a theory on that.
While Participant B took the opposite approach to
the theory:
I don’t, I think this theory bites, frankly. Women are socialized differently now that than statement was made. We are encouraged, well maybe not vent violently, but whether boys socialized to vent violently, but we are encouraged to express our feelings
Participant H agreed with the theory a little by
having this to say:
I agree with that a little. I don’t agree with the part that says women are trained. I don’t think in society they are trained, but I do see where, I do see myself yelling at the tv and getting into it. I agree with that part of it, it does let out frustrations.
As with the other theory
this one only moderately seems to be true for the nine women. As some of the women suggested, watching
wrestling can let out the frustrations they might have. The part about girls being socialized to
control their hostility and to ‘act like ladies,’ doesn’t seem to fit the
society of today. The women of today
have broken all barriers and can do whatever they want and if that means
sometimes ‘acting like a guy,’ all the more power to them to do so.
The third
theory that was read to the interviewees goes as follows; Other observers have
noted the sexual representations inherent in various wrestling holds. Guessing that women spectators are
middle-aged and therefore, were introduced to sex in a period before... sex
became play, there observers have speculated that the woman spectator of
wrestling experiences vicarious gratification from the pain inflicted by one
(male) wrestler upon the other (male) in the sexually suggestive position. It is obvious from the kind of sentiments
expressed by many of the women in the heat of a match that their psyches are
responding to something besides the purely dramatic aspects of wrestling. ‘Lookit that hunk of man!’ is a common
cry. ‘What a build! How would ya like
to date that one. C’mon, Superman, bust him one for me.’ (Appendix C)
This
theory caught many of the nine women off guard and many of them thought this
theory to be, as Participant B put it, ‘reading way too much into it. I mean yeah, I think they’re hot. However, I
am not experiencing any vicarious gratification, by seeing two guys beat each
other up.’ Participant I also took the
same approach B had in saying, ‘I’d have to say that this one out of the ones
read so far is the most out there. We
are obviously not middle aged. And sex
has always been out there for us. So I really don’t believe that one to be
true.’ Participant D comes out and
says, ‘I think somewhere deep down in your psyche that there is something, that
there is that thin line between pain and pleasure.’
Again this
theory seems only be half true. The
argument about women middle-aged and the fact of being introduced to sex later
in life, does not sit well with the females of today’s society. Sex has been an ‘in your face’ topic, at
least for a good portion of the women’s lives that were interviewed. The part of the theory that might have some
truth is the part of the psyches and vicarious gratification. Deep down in your subconscious, the question
is asked, when does pain become pleasure?
The fact that here are many people out there who are into the dominatrix
and S&M role playing, just goes to show you can’t count this part of the
theory out.
The last
theory that was read to the women states, that it is not necessarily the sexual
appeal of the good-looking wrestling hero that attracts women to the
sport. Many of the less attractive
wrestlers receive fan letters from women and are mobbed by women at
arenas. At least one writer believed
this to be due to women’s comparing the ugly stereotype with their husbands or
male friends. The familiar male would
appear relatively more desirable (Appendix C).
This theory seemed to stump the nine women. Many of them thought the theory was interesting and never really
thought about it. Participant D, stated
it best when she said, ‘I think it depends on the female and what her
particular body type, facial features, hair aspects, which she likes, if that
is the kind of person that she enjoys, then yes. But if she likes the Hollywood look then that is the one she is
going to like more. Big and buff versus
Leonardo Dicaprio, scrawny and 12ish.’
This
theory seems to agree with most of the women, in stating that it really doesn’t
apply to the masses. It all depends on
what the woman, who watches, what she wants and likes in a guy. One woman might want the not so attractive
underdog to watch and then someone else might want the big buff Hollywood
looking type.
Background Information
All nine women,
when asked, confirmed that they did watch professional wrestling. Most of the women said that they watch
professional wrestling between once or twice a week. Out of the nine women interviewed, eight said that they only
watch World Wrestling Federation (WWF) while only one stated that she watches
both WWF and World Championship Wrestling (WCW). This greater number that watches WWF over the WCW, seems to show
that the WWF is more popular among people that watch professional wrestling
than the WCW.
Women seem
to start watching professional wrestling at a late age. Most of the interviewees started to watch at
the age of 18 years or older. However
two did state that they used to watch it when they were younger and watched it
until they were in junior high school.
While in high school they stopped watching but started again once they
got into college. This period that they
stopped watching is when the interviewees were in their teenage years. Girls during this time, seem to be more
involved in make-up, puberty, boys and trying to fit in at school. Wrestling seems to not be included as
something cool during this time, so they stop watching. Once in college they know who they are and
aren’t so involved in trying to find their identity and they come back to
wrestling.
Participant
G gave her reason:
I was in elementary school, but there was a gap between sixth grade and junior year in high school, where I didn’t watch it, but I started watching it again when I got into my junior year.
Participant
E gave her reason:
I started at about five, but then I didn’t watch for a while, and then I recently started watching it again about 6 months ago.
Influences and Motivators
Wrestling,
like life, has an influence acting on it.
In trying to find out if there were any family influences on the nine
women interview, there were some interesting answers. Some of the women stated that neither their parents or siblings
watched wrestling. While others stated
that they had a male influencing them, either their dad, brother or both. One women stated that everyone in her family
watched. But the most interesting came
from 20 year-old participant E, who said that it was her grandmother who got
her hooked on professional wrestling.
This is very intriguing because there is a small amount of a female
influence on females to watch wrestling.
Wrestling is such a male-dominated sports entertainment industry, for
the most of the time it is the male influence on the female that gets the women
to watch, not the other way around.
It seems
to be this male influence on the women to watch professional wrestling that
when asked, they state that they don’t normally watch the programs on
television with other women. A few of
the women stated that they don’t watch wrestling with anybody of the same
gender. The majority stated that
sometimes and on rare occasions would they watching with one or two other
females. Participant G stated it in
this way:
Sometimes if someone is walking down the hall and I am watching it, they might stop in.
It seems that a male influence is very present in who women prefer to watch professional wrestling with. Only one female said she does not watch it with males, while the rest stated that they watch it sometimes with males, usually with one or two other males. The males that they tend to watch with are either their boyfriends, brothers or guy friends.
This male
influence on the female to watch wrestling seems to differ from what seems to
motivate the female to watch (Variable List, Appendix E). A small minority stated that there was a
male influence present on why they watched.
Participant B, stated that what motivates her was the hot sweaty
half-naked guys. Participant F said it
was her guy friends who motivated her to watch wrestling, it was just another
way to be with the guys. Participant H,
summed it up as the Rock being her sole motivator.
The other
side of the male influence is the entertainment value. Soap opera, dramatic storylines and fun
entertainment seemed to be the consensus of the bulk of the women on what
motivates them to watch (Appendix E).
Participant
A had this to say:
I like the fake drama. It is very amusing and entertaining.
Participant
D stated it in this way:
It is like a soap opera and it is absolutely hilarious.
Participant
G said this:
You understand the drama in the middle of it when you get older. It is more a soap opera, you are following a story.
Females, it seems from these results that they, are
not solely motivated by a male influence to watch professional wrestling. Many women seem to watch wrestling for the
dramatic aspects and soap opera like storylines of the show more than anything else.
Why Watch?
New Theories
It is this
entertainment aspect of professional wrestling that most of the women
interviewed seemed to get out of watching wrestling. When asked what they get out of watching professional wrestling,
the answers were quite interesting. For
the most part they get entertainment and laughs out of watching (Appendix
E). They also stated that it is
relaxing and a mindless kind of fun, wrestling seems to be something that they
don’t have to seriously do deep thinking about.
Participant
A explains it this way:
I find it relaxing, because it is an escape from reality. It can be fun to watch unrealistic drama.
Participant
D states it is way:
A whole lot of laughs.
Participant F says it like
this:
Wrestling is just one of those things that you just don’t have to think about, you know it is just purely entertainment.
These
statements are fascinating because many times you hear people say that women
think to much or read too much into certain topics. Women defending themselves say they don’t, but maybe they
do. Wrestling is just one of the few
things that can let them escape from reality and they don’t have to think or
worry about life in general.
If they
find it an escape from reality, they sure don’t make it a big part of their
reality. When asked if they reenacted
or recreated parts of the show most of them said no, they didn’t go that
far. Unlike their male counterparts,
who have been known around the United States, to recreate the shows and or
start their own wrestling federations.
A few interviewees said that they use ‘the people’s elbow’ or dialog and
catch phrases of certain wrestlers. And
only, participant F, said she reenacts the show with her friends. She states:
Yeah we actually have done Smackdown before. Everyone, including myself, partakes in the theatrics. We don’t take on character names, but we just do holds or just mess around.
The women
might not go as far as the men in recreating the moves, but they sure seem to
take with them the lingo. When asked if
they use any professional wrestling language in their daily life, the vast
majority of the women said yes. They
use pretty much just the catch phrases and or dialog of the professional
wrestlers. Some of which includes the
phrases, ‘laying the Smackdown’ and ‘Can you smell what the Rock is cookin.’
It is this
fine line, between tv land and reality, that these women don’t seem to want to
cross. They use the language, sometimes
recreate the show, but all said that they have never attended a live
professional wrestling event. And only
about half of those women, said that they would ever want to. It is interesting that they are all for
watching wrestling in the privacy of their rooms. But give them tickets to attend a live event and most wouldn’t
take you up on the offer. This could
show that women might be afraid and embarrassed to let the world know they
watch professional. They sure seem to
give off the impression that it would make them less of a person. Women seem to only take wrestling so far
into their lives.
Yet they
keep tuning in and coming back for more.
When interviewed about wrestling and how it appeals to the female
viewer, most said females tune in for the bodies of the male wrestler to see
their physical size. Another reason
that was stated was that is breaks the feminine mold and gets guys to notice
you. If you can talk wrestling, the
guys will seem to notice you and be impressed.
The women also seem to say that the violence and dramatic soap opera style
is different in wrestling than other shows that they watch.
Participants
E summed all of it up like this:
I know at least for myself and my friends that watch we started watching it again because our boyfriends. Because it is so popular among 20-something guys and they think it is funny and start reenacting it. We are their girlfriends so and we are like sure we will watch it, and then we get so wrapped up in the plot. Like I said, it is a male soap opera. I think that there is also a certain kind of violence to it that we don’t normal express in the female soap opera and other tv shows we watch. I watch Felicity all the time, but there is not a lot of ‘Smackdown’ going down on Felicity. So sometimes you want a little bit of violence. Sometimes you want to get really mad. It kind of lets you live out that whole naughty girl thing.
It is this violence and
physical action, that all the women state is the main difference between what
attracts the male viewers and the female viewers of professional
wrestling. Males, according to them,
seem to like the ‘primal action’ the ‘sheer violence’ of professional
wrestling, to get ‘their testosterone pumping.’ Where as women seem to tune in to watch for the dramatic
storylines, good looking wrestlers and its pure entertainment value.
‘Real’ v. ‘Fake’
It is this
notion of wrestling’s entertainment value and what is ‘real’ versus what is
‘fake’ that seems to have no definite answer.
The argument over wrestling being ‘fake’ or ‘real’ has taken over a life
of its own, with no clear winner to declare.
All the women interviewed argued their points.
Participant
B explains her view in this way:
I think the argument is pretty pointless. I mean thousands of people watch professional wrestling. I think it is both. I think there is a lot of showmanship but there is really big chance of physical injury.
Participant
C sees it like this:
Well since a lot of it is fake and some of it is real. And you can usually tell what is real and what is fake. I think its pretty much, I think it is real. I mean I get mad sometimes when people say ‘it’s fake.’
Participant
G had this way to look at the issue:
It’s fake, I mean everyone knows it, if you don’t too bad. The fact is that it is a real sport and they do do real activity that does take real physical exertion out of you. And they have to train for all the physical activity that they do. I do realize that some of them do really get hurt, so that is the real part of the wrestling as far as the scenarios and the marriages, that is all fake, it is just part of the industry.
The
argument of whether professional wrestling is ‘real’ or ‘fake’ still goes on
with no end in sight. No one can come
to agree with one side or the other. It
all depends on the viewers perception of what they have come to believe is
‘real’ and what is ‘fake.’ Is it ‘real’
because there is the possibility of injury or ‘fake’ because it is
choreographed. The answer is a toss up
and the answer seems to change from viewer to viewer.
The Portrayals of Women
One answer
that seems to be consistent, among all the women that were interviewed, was
their answer on how they think women are portrayed in professional
wrestling. Words such as degrading,
negative, hoes and sex objects were encompassed in all their answers. There was also the flip side of this bad
side. Many of the women expressed how
one women wrestler in particular, Chyna, is a ‘woman of obvious strength, who
is competing on the same level of men’ as stated by Participant F. No one seems really happy about the way
women are portrayed in wrestling.
Participant A says that they, ‘portray an attitude about
themselves.’ While Participant H states
that, ‘I don’t like the way they are portrayed. But the women that participate set themselves up for it.’
When asked
how women should be portrayed in professional wrestling, Participant G summed
it up very well by saying, ‘In every respectful way possible.’ There were also comments on women being
‘portrayed as equals to the men,’ having the women partake in a ‘more serious
role, and bigger roles behind the scenes,’ and have the women be ‘sexy in a
classy way.’
Then
again, some say, like Participant I, that in ‘that context that’s the way they
should be because, that is what you want from them right then.’ Or take Participant H’s response, ‘for the
entertainment, I don’t think there is any other way to portray them to make it
interesting.’ Breaking down all these
answers, it looks like these nine women suggest that the professional wrestling
industry try to dress sex down, make it classy, be respectful to the women
being portrayed and to the women who watch and not be too overly offensive.
Suggestions to Change Wrestling
Along with
these suggestions about the portrayals of women in this sports entertainment
industry, they came up with a few more when asked if they would they change
anything about professional wrestling.
Suggestions such as, ‘making it less choreographed,’ ‘change the way
they treat women,’ invent or come up with new ‘gimmicks, the tables and chairs,
just don’t do it anymore’ and have more of an emphases on ‘don’t try this at
home.’ One positive aspect of
professional wrestling that has occurred according to Participant A is:
A good thing that the WWF is doing is getting it audience to register to vote. Both the Rock and Chyna were at the Democratic and Republican National Convention. I even registered to vote through WWF.com
The sports entertainment industry has a lot of work ahead for them in the future if they want to keep the women tuning in day after day, according to the nine women interviewed.
Discussion
The nine
women who interviewed and discussed the reasons why they watch professional wrestling
have come up with some theories of their own.
Instead of watching for the ‘good versus evil’ or to let ‘their
frustrations out,’ as the old theories state, it is out with the old, in with
the new. There seems to be a move
towards four new theories on why women watch professional wrestling. This theories include watching for
entertainment value, the soap opera storylines, mindless fun and the guy
wrestlers. The women interviewed for
this study have given some insightful information on why the 20-something women
of today watch professional wrestling and how much of it they take into their
personal lives.
It seems
the tides have changed and it is has only pure entertainment value in their
lives. The women want the laughs, they
want the soap opera type storylines and they don’t seem to really want to have
to think deeply or be deeply involved about professional wrestling. They also don’t let professional wrestling
take over their lives, like it could with their male counterparts, as some of
the women interviewed suggested. The
lingo and catch phrases seems to be the only thing that they take into their
daily lives. They don’t want to cross
that line between reality and tv, and have wrestling take over their lives.
The reason
for the shift from the old views of why women watch, to the new views, could be
in part from the changes that professional wrestling has gone through in the
last part of the 20th century.
In the beginning wrestling was 100% sport, and gradually it has become
almost 100% entertainment. They don’t
call it a sports entertainment industry today for nothing. Nevertheless those
interviewed still can not agree on whether wrestling is ‘fake’ or ‘real.’
Times have
changed, society has changed and so have the ideals of women. Professional wrestling industry take
warning, the women of today don’t seem to care much for the scantily clad women
of wrestling. You want them to keep
tuning in day after day, give them something of what they want. You don’t have to sacrifice everything. We all know that sex sells and it keeps the
guys coming back for more. If all the
women interviewed got their way, the way women were portrayed in professional
wrestling would change. But as one of
them suggests, make it sexy in a classy way.
Some who were interviewed thought Chyna was a good start, she is a
‘women of strength’ and glamorous at the same time.
This
research is just a start, the possibilities for future research are
endless. The research conducted here
was just a small sample of private college students in the Midwest. The women that were interviewed all came
from upper middle class backgrounds and go to a private Catholic college. More accurate or in depth answers and
theories could be found if you were to interview women of all economic and
educational backgrounds.
With
unlimited time and unlimited resources the possibility to interview those women
who don’t watch it, and get and outsiders perspective would also come in
handy. One could also interview males
on why they think women watch professional wrestling, as another
perspective. It is worth while to look
at these other groups and get their takes on the theories that were presented
to the women of this study and also the theories that these same women gave on
why they watch.
So whether
women watch professional wrestling for pure entertainment value or good versus
evil, professional wrestling remains a staple in American culture no matter
what background you come from.
Albano,
L., Sugar, B., & Woodson, R. (1999). The complete idiot’s guide to pro
wrestling. New York: Macmillan Publishing.
This
book is the complete guide of everything one would want to know about professional wrestling and more. It gives you the history of professional
wrestling, play by play action of past events and the inside scoop of how the
wrestling matches go from start to finish.
It also lists the wrestlers and matches they have been in and for what
federation/company they wrestle for.
Ball, M.
(1990). Professional wrestling: As ritual drama in American popular culture.
New York: Edwin Mellen Press.
The
entire book is involved in discussing the comprehensive view of professional
wrestling. From historical analysis,
interviews and surveys of participants and non-participants to content analysis
of televised matches, observations of live matches, and participant observation
of wrestling audiences. In addition to
the structure and themes of the ritual dramas that have created the unexpected
success of this pop-culture phenomenon.
Berger, A.
(1996). Manufacturing desire: Media, popular culture, and everyday life.
New Jersey: Transaction Publishers.
The chapters on television and television as an instrument of terror. These chapters deal with violence on television, media effects, and the disorientation due to television.
Brants,
K., Hermes, J., & Zoonen, L. (Eds.). (1998). The media in question:
Popular cultures and public interests. California: Sage Publications.
Chapter dealing with stories of violence and the public interest, violence and the corporate imperatives, the industrial and electronic revolutions and citizen action.
Corbin, J., & Strauss, A. (1990). Basics of
Qualitative Research. Newbury, CA:
Sage.
Section in book dealing with the open coding process for qualitative research.
Holmstrom,
D. (1998, December 18). Muscle-tainment!. Christian Science Monitor, 91(12),
13-14.
Describes
the increasingly obscene culture surrounding professional wrestling in the
United States. Competition between the
WCW and the WWF. The popularity of
professional wrestling. Questions about its influence on children.
Investigative
reports: The unreal story of professional wrestling. [video] (1998). New
York: Arts & Entertainment.
This
video goes inside the history of professional wrestling and behind the scenes
to give the viewer and up close and personal tour of the in’s and out’s of the
world of professional wrestling.
Jensen, J.
(1998, August 17). Wrestling foes maintstream draws big ratings, sponsors. Advertising
Age, 69(33), 3-5.
Reports
on the effects of the World Wrestling Federation (WWF) and World Championship
Wrestling (WCW) becoming more mainstream.
How television ratings of WWF and WCW have increased during the late
1990's.
Kiss my
ass. (1999, August 28). Economist, 352(8134), 22-24.
Discusses
the popularity of professional wrestling.
Discusses possible reasons for professional wrestling’s popularity,
fears raised by the amount of sex and violence and racism present in
professional wrestling.
Kleiner,
C. (1999, May 17). Wrestling’s cult following. U.S. News & World Report,
126(19), 54.
Small
article discussing professional wrestling and the college students that are
enthusiastic devotees.
Mazer, S.
(1998). Professional wrestling: Sport and spectacle. Jackson: University
Press of Mississippi.
The
chapter entitled What the World is Watching dealing with what the actual viewer
does watch and the difference between real/fake and good/bad. Also discusses the promotions, the
advertisements and the amount of money made during an event.
McBrien,
J. (1999, October). New texts, new tools: An argument for media literacy. Education
Leadership, 57(2), 76-80.
Probes into the teaching of media literacy in the United States, Approaches to media education and the benefit of media education on students.
McHugh, C.
(1999, April). Ready to rumble. Entertainment Design, 33(4), 36-38.
Relates
the author’s experience during her high school days when they trained to become
a journalist. Observations on covering
wrestling sport and the role of the cable network in popularizing sports.
Morton, G.
(1985). Wrestling to rasslin: ancient sport to American spectacle. Ohio:
Bowling Green State University Popular Press.
The
chapter on professional wrestling as American ritual deals with whether or not
people believe professional wrestling, which combines sport and drama, is a
ritual while theater and actual sport such as football are not.
Rickard,
J. (1999, Summer). ‘The spectacle of excess’: The emergence of modern
professional wrestling in the United States and Australia. Journal of
Popular Culture, 33(1), 129-138.
Looks
at the transition of professional wrestling from a legitimate sport with its
roots in folk tradition to a spectacle of excess. Highlights on the career of George Hackenschmidt, who bridged the
transition of wrestling.
Real, M.
(1996). Exploring media culture: A guide. California: Sage Publications.
The
chapter dealing with ritual participation and the case of mediated sports and
the “deep fan”. Along with the chapter
of Reception Theory and pornography and violence in media culture.
Rossellini,
L. (1999, May 17). Lords of the ring. U.S. News & World Report, 126(19),
52-59.
Examines
the popularity of professional wrestling in the United States and the work of
the WWF and its competitor WCW.
Questions about the effects of wrestling on youths, especially
boys. The views of Vince McMahon on
sports entertainment.
Schrader,
M., Wann, D., & Wilson, A. (1999, March). Sport fan motivation:
Questionnaire validation, comparisons by sport and relationship to athletic
motivation. Journal of Sport Behavior, 22(1), 114-140.
Presents
information on studies on the Sport Fan Motivation Scale (SFMS), an instrument
designed to measure different motives of sports fans. Method of the studies, results and discussions.
Wann, D.
(1995, November). Preliminary validation of the sport fan motivation scale. Journal
of Sport and Social Issues, 19(4), 377-399.
Focuses
on two studies that attempts to construct a measure of sport fan
motivation. Motivating factors for
sport fandom. Description of the
23-item Likert-scale measure, description of the Sport Fan Motivation Scale and
possible uses for the measurements.
World
Championship Wrestling. (2000, February 25).
[On-line]. Available: .
The
web site for the World Championship Wrestling.
News and information on wrestlers, matches and the company.
World
Wrestling Federation. (2000, February 25). [On-line]. Available: .
The
web site for the World Wrestling Federation.
News and information on wrestlers, matches and the company.
Appendix A
Consent Form
My name is Amanda Burns and I am a senior
communications major at Saint Mary’s College.
You are invited to participate in a study of why women watch
professional wrestling. Many theories
concerning the popularity of wrestling as a spectator sport among women have
been made. None of these theories have
ever been studied in great detail. The
benefits of this research will give the public some understanding of why women
watch this male dominated sport. You
have been chosen for this study because I have prior knowledge that you are a
professional wrestling fan or have been recommend to me by someone who knows
you are a professional wrestling fan.
I have selected you to be involved in an
extended interview with myself, which will be audio taped for transcription
purposes only. The interview should
take no longer than an hour to complete.
There are no risks or discomforts to you or myself. In this study I am trying to find out why
professional wrestling is appealing to its female fans.
This consent form with your signature will
be stored separately from the data collected.
Tapes will not be available to anyone but myself. Upon completion of transcribing the tapes,
they will be erased.
Your decision whether or not to participate
is voluntary and if you choose not to participate there will be no penalty
against you. If you decide to
participate you are free to discontinue participation at any time.
If you have any questions please ask
them. If you have any additional
questions later I will be happy to answer them. You can reach me at (284-5034).
You may keep the top part of this consent form for your records.
________________________________________________________________
I
have read and understand the above information and agree to participate in this
study.
________________________________ ____________
Participant’s Signature Date
________________________________ ____________ Researcher’s
Signature
Date
Appendix B
Interview
Schedule
Age:
Where
are you from:
What
is your major:
Do
you watch Professional wrestling:
How
often do you watch:
Do
you watch WWF, WCW, ECW, other, or a combination:
At
what age did you start watching professional wrestling:
Do/Did
your parents and/or siblings watch professional wrestling:
What
do you think motivates you to watch professional wrestling:
Do
you watch with other people of the same gender, if so how many:
Do
you watch with other people of the opposite gender, if so how many:
Do
you ever reenact/recreate parts of the show:
What
do you get out of watching professional wrestling:
Do
you have a favorite professional wrestler, and why do you identify with them:
Do
you use any professional wrestling language in your daily life:
Have
you ever attended a live professional wrestling event:
What
is your take on the ‘real’ verus ‘fake’ issue of professional wrestling:
What
do you think are the reasons why professional wrestling is appealing to its
female viewers:
What
do you think about the way women are portrayed in professional wrestling:
How
do you think women should be portrayed:
If
you could change anything about professional wrestling, what would you change
and why:
What
do you think are the differences between professional wrestling’s
attractiveness toward it’s male viewers and it’s female viewers:
I
am going to read a few of the theories concerning the popularity of wrestling
as a spectator sport among women, what do you think about these theories:
Appendix C
Appendix C
Four theories on why women
watch professional wrestling.
From Pages 58 and 59 of
Professional Wrestling: As
Ritual Drama in American Popular Culture by Ball
One
theory says that women are the ‘traditional custodians of morality,’ and are
especially attracted to the morality play between the forces of good and evil.
Another
theory states that girls are socialized to control their hostility and to ‘act
like ladies.’ Wrestling acts as a kind
of catharsis, allowing them to vent their frustration and their aggressive
feelings.
Other
observers have noted the sexual representations inherent in various wrestling
holds. Guessing that women spectators
are middle-aged and therefore, were introduced to sex in a period before... sex
became play, there observers have speculated that the woman spectator of
wrestling experiences vicarious gratification from the pain inflicted by one
(male) wrestler upon the other (male) in the sexually suggestive position. It is obvious from the kind of sentiments
expressed by many of the women in the heat of a match that their psyches are
responding to something besides the purely dramatic aspects of wrestling. ‘Lookit that hunk of man!’ is a common
cry. ‘What a build! How would ya like
to date that one. C’mon, Superman, bust him one for me.’
Another
theory says that it is not necessarily the sexual appeal of the good-looking
wrestling hero that attracts women to the sport. Many of the less attractive wrestlers receive fan letters from
women and are mobbed by women at arenas.
At least one writer believed this to be due to women’s comparing the
ugly stereotype with their husbands or male friends. The familiar male would appear relatively more desirable.
Transcripts
Participant
A
Researcher:
What is your age?
Participant
A: 21
R:
Where are you from?
A:
El Paso, Texas
R:
What is your major?
A:
Double major in Sociology and Philosophy
R:
Do you watch Professional Wrestling?
A:
Yes
R:
How often do you watch?
A:
Twice a week
R:
Do you watch WWF, WCW, ECW, or a combination?
A:
Only WWF
R:
At what age did you start watching professional wrestling?
A:
21
R: Do/did your parents
and/or siblings watch professional wrestling?
A: Yes, my brother does, he
was the one that got me started watching.
R: What do you think
motivates you to watch professional wrestling?
A: That’s a hard one. I find
all the action and hitting people fun.
I like the fake drama. It is
very amusing and entertaining.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the same gender, if so how many?
A: Well, when I get the
change I watch with my younger cousin sometimes, she is 13.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the opposite gender, if so how many?
A:
Just one my brother, when I am at home.
R:
Do you ever reenact/recreate parts of the show?
A:
No, I try to stay away from that.
R:
What do you get out of watching professional wrestling?
A: I find it relaxing,
because it is an escape from reality.
It can be fun to watch unrealistic drama.
R: Do you have a favorite
professional wrestler, and why do you identify with them?
A: Triple H, um, I really
don’t identify with him. He is a big
white man and I am a small Hispanic woman.
What I do like about him is his characteristics.
R: Do you use any
professional wrestling language in your daily life?
A:
No.
R:
Have you ever attended a live professional wrestling event?
A: No.
R: What is your take on the
‘real’ versus ‘fake’ issue of professional wrestling?
A: Sometimes I wish some of
the things that they do were real. I
think I know that what they do is staged.
If there were more things that were real and they were telling the truth
it might make it more interesting to watch.
I like the fakeness, so that no one gets hurt, but I wish it were real.
R: What do you think are the
reasons why professional wrestling is appealing to its female viewers?
A: I think for me some
people characterize me as some feminine person. When I watch wrestling I break that mold. I am diverse and well rounded.
R: What do you think about
the way women are portrayed in professional wrestling?
A: Wow, um, I think that
women in professional wrestling portray an attitude about themselves. The way people see them is the way they want
to be seen. They do it for themself for
different characteristics.
R:
How do you think women should be portrayed?
A: I don’t have a problem on
how they should be portrayed. Stephanie
McMahon Helmsly seems strong. She doesn’t
portray herself as an airhead. She is
strong and independent and unique the way she is. Women of professional wrestling should be of the same caliber.
R: If you could change
anything about professional wrestling, what would you change and why?
A: Kind of a tough one, I
think since a lot of people watch it, it could definitely use some positive
aspects. I have some problems with
violence in the media. There are
children that watch wrestling and most of the time the stuff shown is
aggressive. They should focus on not
only friendship, but amicable stuff, stuff that is not as aggressive in
nature. A good thing that the WWF is
doing is getting it audience to register to vote. Both the Rock and Chyna were at the Democratic and Republican
National Convention. I even registered
to vote through WWF.com.
R: What do you think are the
differences between professional wrestling’s attractiveness toward it’s male
viewers and it’s female viewers?
A: Weird, for me I like to
see aggression, same as male viewers, like my brother and cousins. I am not sure about women, I don’t know too
many women who watch it like me. I feel
transformed into a guy while watching.
R: I am going to read a few
of the theories concerning the popularity of wrestling as a spectator sport
among women, what do you think about these theories? OK, here is the first one.
One theory says that women are the ‘traditional custodians of morality,’
and are especially attracted to the morality play between the forces of good
and evil.
A: That could be a
possibility, I haven’t been watching all that long. My perspective is I like the ultimate good. Right now, my wrestler is one of the good
guys and I really like that. I really
identify by this theory.
R: Another theory states
that girls are socialized to control their hostility and to ‘act like
ladies.’ Wrestling acts as a kind of
catharsis, allowing them to vent their frustration and their aggressive
feelings. What do you think about this
theory?
A: I can identify with this
one. I was raised and a southern
belle. Always acting like a lady and
was constantly told not to act like a dude.
Watching wrestling twice a week gives me an escape. I can understand why there is a theory on
that.
R: Other observers have
noted the sexual representations inherent in various wrestling holds. Guessing that women spectators are
middle-aged and therefore, were introduced to sex in a period before... sex
became play, there observers have speculated that the woman spectator of
wrestling experiences vicarious gratification from the pain inflicted by one
(male) wrestler upon the other (male) in the sexually suggestive position. It is obvious from the kind of sentiments
expressed by many of the women in the heat of a match that their psyches are
responding to something besides the purely dramatic aspects of wrestling. ‘Lookit that hunk of man!’ is a common
cry. ‘What a build! How would ya like
to date that one. C’mon, Superman, bust him one for me.’ What are your takes on this theory?
A: Referring back to my wrestler,
I find him very attractive and stimulating.
I love the power he has. It is a
turn on. That Herculean strength you
don’t see that often especially when he fights over his wife with other
wrestlers. Sometimes I wish I was his
wife. Him being the protector is very
appealing.
R: Another theory says that
it is not necessarily the sexual appeal of the good-looking wrestling hero that
attracts women to the sport. Many of
the less attractive wrestlers receive fan letters from women and are mobbed by
women at arenas. At least one writer
believed this to be due to women’s comparing the ugly stereotype with their
husbands or male friends. The familiar
male would appear relatively more desirable.
What do you think about this one?
A: Um, I think the ugly dude
is more attractive, more realistic. The
ugly guys are treated last. But because of strength and aggressiveness is more
appealing even though they don’t have the Hollywood look.
Participant
B
Researcher:
What is your age?
Participant
B: 21
R:
Where are you from?
B:
Buchanan, Michigan
R:
What is your major?
B:
Literature
R:
Do you watch Professional Wrestling?
B:
Yes, I do.
R:
How often do you watch?
B:
um, Mondays and Thursdays
R:
Do you watch WWF, WCW, ECW, other ,or a combination?
B:
WWF, I can’t stand WCW
R:
At what age did you start watching professional wrestling?
B:
20
R: Do/did your parents
and/or siblings watch professional wrestling?
B: No.
R: What do you think
motivates you to watch professional wrestling?
B: Hot sweaty guys that are
half-naked
R: Do you watch with other
people of the same gender, if so how many?
B: um, depends, sometimes I
do generally one or two.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the opposite gender, if so how many?
B:
No.
R:
Do you ever reenact/recreate parts of the show?
B: No. I am not stupid, they
say pretty much, you see those commercials don’t do this at home, we are
professionals
R:
What do you get out of watching professional wrestling?
B: It is a nice way to relax
and a mindless kind of fun. I don’t have to think about anything else.
R: Do you have a favorite
professional wrestler, and why do you identify with them?
B: I do, the
Undertaker. And I identify with him
because I guess he is the bad boy. And when I started to watch he was in his
lord of darkness mode and I am a Pagan so I can identify with him that way.
R: Do you use any
professional wrestling language in your daily life?
B:
No.
R:
Have you ever attended a live professional wrestling event?
B: Unfortunately no.
R: What is your take on the
‘real’ versus ‘fake’ issue of professional wrestling?
B: I think the argument is
pretty pointless. I mean, thousands of people watch professional wrestling and
WWF has the whole Smackdown the Vote and they have registered over 200 thousand
new voters, whether or not it is real or fake it doesn’t matter, people still
watch. Do I think it is real or fake? I think it is both. I think there is a lot of showmanship but
there is a really big chance of physical injury, um, real wrestling moves.
R: What do you think are the
reasons why professional wrestling is appealing to its female viewers?
B: Hot sweaty half-naked men.
I am telling you, I don’t know any girl that would turn down a hot sweaty
half-naked man.
R: What do you think about
the way women are portrayed in professional wrestling?
B: I think that sucks. They
do the whole, gravy/mud wrestling type of thing. The only one women wrestler that I think is any good is Chyna.
Because they don’t stick her in the gravy boat and have her get her clothes
ripped off of her.
R:
How do you think women should be portrayed?
B: I think they should get a
more serious role, not necessary the sex kitten, big-boobed role. And things can’t change in front of the
camera without women having a bigger role with the behind the scenes stuff.
R: If you could change
anything about professional wrestling, what would you change and why?
B: I don’t know, let me
think, what would I change... I would definitely change the way they treat
women. That is like my big pet peve,
other than that, they are doing a good job.
Oh all those Summer Slams and the rest of the Pay-Per-View events they
need to have those so those of us with out Pay-Per-View can watch.
R: What do you think are the
differences between professional wrestling’s attractiveness toward it’s male
viewers and it’s female viewers?
B: Yeah I think guys watch
it, It is like football, they don’t watch it for the guys in tight pants, like
women do, at least that I why I watch football. Um, but they watch the violent contact sports to get their
testosterone pumping. And of course they have the women and the gravy.
R: I am going to read a few
of the theories concerning the popularity of wrestling as a spectator sport
among women, what do you think about these theories? OK, here is the first one.
One theory says that women are the ‘traditional custodians of morality,’
and are especially attracted to the morality play between the forces of good
and evil.
B: I think that in a way
that is very true. They do have the
good and evil characters of good and evil of wrestling. It is not like Superman
and Lex Luther, but like I said before, the undertaker came on as the lord of
darkness and he was unpopular for a while there, because he was the lord of
darkness, now he is back, and he has this whole Texas thing going on, he is not
the lord of darkness anymore. And he is
not nearly as unpopular as he was. The
good guys and the bad guys change a lot and just in the past 12 months that I
have been watching it, I can see that.
R: Another theory states
that girls are socialized to control their hostility and to ‘act like
ladies.’ Wrestling acts as a kind of
catharsis, allowing them to vent their frustration and their aggressive
feelings. What do you think about this
theory?
B: I don’t, I think this
theory bites, frankly. Women are
socialized differently now that than statement was made. We are encouraged,
well maybe not vent violently, but whether boys socialized to vent violently,
but we are encouraged to express our feelings.
R: Other observers have
noted the sexual representations inherent in various wrestling holds. Guessing that women spectators are
middle-aged and therefore, were introduced to sex in a period before... sex
became play, there observers have speculated that the woman spectator of
wrestling experiences vicarious gratification from the pain inflicted by one
(male) wrestler upon the other (male) in the sexually suggestive position. It is obvious from the kind of sentiments
expressed by many of the women in the heat of a match that their psyches are
responding to something besides the purely dramatic aspects of wrestling. ‘Lookit that hunk of man!’ is a common
cry. ‘What a build! How would ya like
to date that one. C’mon, Superman, bust him one for me.’ What are your takes on this theory?
B: I think they are reading
way too much into it. I mean yeah, I
think Jesus Christ there hot. However, I am not experiencing any vicarious
gratification, by seeing two guys beat each other up.
R: Another theory says that
it is not necessarily the sexual appeal of the good-looking wrestling hero that
attracts women to the sport. Many of
the less attractive wrestlers receive fan letters from women and are mobbed by
women at arenas. At least one writer
believed this to be due to women’s comparing the ugly stereotype with their
husbands or male friends. The familiar
male would appear relatively more desirable.
What do you think about this one?
B: I think it is an interesting
theory, I have never thought about it before.
I mean my boyfriend still is no Tom Cruise, um, he was a wrestler
perfectly. But I guess it is odd that I am dating a wrestler while I am a big
fan of professional wrestling. I don’t think it is quite the way they put
it. I mean, there are some really hot
Hollywood types out there. Like the
Rock or Edge and Christian.
Participant
C
Researcher:
What is your age?
Participant
C: 21
R:
Where are you from?
C:
Arlington Heights, Illinois
R:
What is your major?
C: Music Education
R:
Do you watch Professional Wrestling?
C:
Yes
R:
How often do you watch?
C:
Twice a week
R:
Do you watch WWF, WCW, ECW, or a combination?
C:
WWF and WCW
R:
At what age did you start watching professional wrestling?
C:
18
R: Do/did your parents
and/or siblings watch professional wrestling?
C: No.
R: What do you think
motivates you to watch professional wrestling?
C: I find it exciting, it is
just good entertainment
R: Do you watch with other
people of the same gender, if so how many?
C: um, No.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the opposite gender, if so how many?
C:
Sometimes I watch it with one of my guy friends.
R:
Do you ever reenact/recreate parts of the show?
C:
oh, yeah, like the people’s elbow and what the wrestlers say.
R:
What do you get out of watching professional wrestling?
C: Um, nothing really, I
just watch it for fun and for entertainment.
It’s not I want to be a wrestler.
R: Do you have a favorite
professional wrestler, and why do you identify with them?
C: Triple H, because he is
hot. He is good looking. He is the boss, he is just way up there. I
can identify with he because he always wants to succeed and like be the best, and
so do I.
R: Do you use any
professional wrestling language in your daily life?
C:
Yeah a little.
R:
Have you ever attended a live professional wrestling event?
C: No, I haven’t. But I
would.
R: What is your take on the
‘real’ versus ‘fake’ issue of professional wrestling?
C: Well since a lot of it is
fake and some of it is real. And you can usually tell what is real and what is
fake. I think its pretty much, I think
it is real. I mean I get mad sometimes when people say ‘it’s fake.’
R: What do you think are the
reasons why professional wrestling is appealing to its female viewers?
C: I think because, the
wrestlers are in their top physical shape, like there physic, and usually girls
like that thing, guys that are like big and buff and stuff.
R: What do you think about
the way women are portrayed in professional wrestling?
C: I think the women
wrestlers, like Chyna and stuff, they get a lot of respect because they win a
lot, but she does other things. She is
not just a wrestler all the time. But I
think the other women that come out with other wrestlers are just look at like
sex symbols. Everyone just wants to
look at them.
R:
How do you think women should be portrayed?
C: I think they should be
portrayed as like how the men are portrayed, should be like as equals. I think the men get more tv time and the
women don’t. I think it should be equal
and they should be treated like the same way as the men. They don’t just let
things slide just for the women.
R: If you could change
anything about professional wrestling, what would you change and why?
C: Have it be on more often.
No. I think, maybe try and get new wrestlers to come into the business. Like it is just the same people all the
time. And I would like to see the amateurs
wrestling.
R: What do you think are the
differences between professional wrestling’s attractiveness toward it’s male
viewers and it’s female viewers?
C: I think it attracts the
male viewers because, like its their bonding time and I think that they want to
be like those guys. They want to
reenact what they do and be as strong and as buff as those guys. And I think I think the female viewers watch
it because they just want to watch the wrestlers, not just necessarily to watch
what is going on, but to see the wrestlers, because most of them are good
looking.
R: I am going to read a few
of the theories concerning the popularity of wrestling as a spectator sport
among women, what do you think about these theories? OK, here is the first one.
One theory says that women are the ‘traditional custodians of morality,’
and are especially attracted to the morality play between the forces of good
and evil.
C: I think that is true.
Because women always, well most of the time, want to see the evil people
win. It is not always about the good
guy winning. Sometimes they want to,
they find it exciting to watch the evil person, and cheer for the underdog.
R: Another theory states
that girls are socialized to control their hostility and to ‘act like
ladies.’ Wrestling acts as a kind of
catharsis, allowing them to vent their frustration and their aggressive
feelings. What do you think about this
theory?
C: I don’t agree with this
theory. I don’t watch it to vent my
feelings. I just watch it because I
think it is fun to watch not necessarily to let all my anger out. I don’t feel like angry or anything when I
watch it. I don’t think it changes
their mood to be aggressive or anything like that.
R: Other observers have
noted the sexual representations inherent in various wrestling holds. Guessing that women spectators are
middle-aged and therefore, were introduced to sex in a period before... sex
became play, there observers have speculated that the woman spectator of
wrestling experiences vicarious gratification from the pain inflicted by one
(male) wrestler upon the other (male) in the sexually suggestive position. It is obvious from the kind of sentiments
expressed by many of the women in the heat of a match that their psyches are
responding to something besides the purely dramatic aspects of wrestling. ‘Lookit that hunk of man!’ is a common
cry. ‘What a build! How would ya like
to date that one. C’mon, Superman, bust him one for me.’ What are your takes on this theory?
C: I could see how they are
saying that, but I don’t relate to that really. Like I think wrestling is exciting, but I don’t get turned on by
it. I think it is exciting, and I can
see how some might get too excited over it.
Like your adrenalin is pumping because your watching this match and it
is so exciting, so I can see how that can happen. But in my case I don’t relate to that theory.
R: Another theory says that
it is not necessarily the sexual appeal of the good-looking wrestling hero that
attracts women to the sport. Many of
the less attractive wrestlers receive fan letters from women and are mobbed by
women at arenas. At least one writer
believed this to be due to women’s comparing the ugly stereotype with their
husbands or male friends. The familiar
male would appear relatively more desirable.
What do you think about this one?
C: I could see that I
guess. Because like if I think Triple H
is hot and my friend would be like he’s ugly, what are you talking about. And like I don’t know. And maybe he isn’t necessarily and I can see
how like those people could relate to that.
Not the hot wrestlers, but the ones that are like normal or
whatever. But I don’t know, I usually
go by on just who wins. Who has won a
lot of matches not really by like, I mean I do go by their looks but by who
wins the match, you know. Doesn’t have to with their looks.
Participant
D
Researcher:
What is your age?
Participant
D: 22
R:
Where are you from?
D:
Mishawaka, Indiana
R:
What is your major?
D:
French and History
R:
Do you watch Professional Wrestling?
D:
Yes
R:
How often do you watch?
D:
Once a week
R:
Do you watch WWF, WCW, ECW, or a combination?
D:
WWF
R:
At what age did you start watching professional wrestling?
D:
18
R: Do/did your parents
and/or siblings watch professional wrestling?
D: Nope.
R: What do you think
motivates you to watch professional wrestling?
D: It is like a soap opera
and it is absolutely hilarious. Cause
everything is fake on there. It just
makes you laugh.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the same gender, if so how many?
D: Occasionally, with two or
three.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the opposite gender, if so how many?
D:
Once.
R:
Do you ever reenact/recreate parts of the show?
D:
No. I don’t go that far.
R:
What do you get out of watching professional wrestling?
D: A whole lot of laughs.
R: Do you have a favorite
professional wrestler, and why do you identify with them?
D: Yes. I don’t know, I guess cause their
interesting. You pick one character
that you like to look at, and you follow that particular character through his
trials and tribulations. Well I like a
couple of them. I like Triple H and
occasionally, I like the Undertaker, it depends on what he is doing. Sometimes I like watching the Rock because
he is absolutely off the wall and bonkers sometimes.
R: Do you use any
professional wrestling language in your daily life?
D: yeah, like when Stone
Cold Steve Austin says ‘Laying the Smackdown’ or about ‘candy asses’ those come
out quite frequently.
R:
Have you ever attended a live professional wrestling event?
D: No, I would love to.
R: What is your take on the
‘real’ versus ‘fake’ issue of professional wrestling?
D: I would say that most of
the wrestling they do is choreographed.
But I think they do it in a realist way to make it seem real. But I do think that most of it is not. I
mean it is not two people who just walk out into the arena and just duking it
out with no prior coordination. I mean
they know exactly where their body is going to be placed. And if you watch it really closely enough
you can see that they really did hit them as hard. Or they went to hit him and it completely missed and it just, the
other person reacted just as they were suppose to react.
R: What do you think are the
reasons why professional wrestling is appealing to its female viewers?
D: I think the guys. I think it is the body type of the
guys. Yeah and maybe some of the
attitude they portray. Like that bad
boy attitude it is appealing to good people who are ‘nice.’
R: What do you think about
the way women are portrayed in professional wrestling?
D: I am not really happy
with it. I know that there are some
female wrestlers out there that look buff.
But if you look at the outfits that they are putting the females in, I mean
they are like ‘lets show of how big your bosoms are,’ ‘lets show off your crotch,’
‘lets show off your ass.’ You know, in that sense I find it degrading, because
it puts women it shows women in a negative aspect. It shows them as nothing but a sex object and that is all that
they are there for. Even though there
are some female wrestlers that are up there wrestling. But even still they are portrayed as a
female butch sex object.
R:
How do you think women should be portrayed?
D: Well, um, With out taking
away from the wrestling factor that is in it, I think that they could do more
with having a portrayal of women not so much as like a sexual object. But showing that you can be a female
wrestler and be sexy, but sexy in a classy way, not sexy in the trashy way they
have them on there.
R: If you could change
anything about professional wrestling, what would you change and why?
D: Making it less
choreographed, having the element of surprised in there for some of the
wrestlers. Changing the way women are
viewed. Mainly because the audience
that isn’t maybe from the middle class or upper middle class, tend to be from
lower economic fields and if they are watching this, and they see how women are
treated on the show, then they are going to think that, especially children,
that is ok to treat females that way and its not. Or that is or to treat other friends, you know, if they are going
out and reenacting parts of the show, its not.
I think the wrestlers need to take responsibility for what they are
portraying on the shows and say like, ‘Look, what we are doing is job, its not
real, we’re not beating the crap out of each other when we are in the ring,
because we are all friends. You
shouldn’t be doing this outside unless you are monitored by someone who is in
the wrestling field or is a professional instructor of some sort. To make is clear, especially cause younger
viewers, um, that this isn’t like appropriate behavior.
R: What do you think are the
differences between professional wrestling’s attractiveness toward it’s male
viewers and it’s female viewers?
D: I think it is less
attractive to the female viewers because most of it is geared toward young
adolescent males or males under the age of thirty. I think that for guys, it portrays the aggression aspect of their
mentality. That they don’t get a chance
to normally get to express in every day circumstances. I guess you could say that it is kind of
like when they watch it, they are kind living out those actions through the
wrestlers. For females, I think it is a
completely different aspect. I think
they are looking at if more for the fun factor and the sexual attractiveness of
the males.
R: I am going to read a few
of the theories concerning the popularity of wrestling as a spectator sport
among women, what do you think about these theories? OK, here is the first one.
One theory says that women are the ‘traditional custodians of morality,’
and are especially attracted to the morality play between the forces of good
and evil.
D: That is a possibility, I
would say mainly like if I was a female viewer and I was watching maybe with a
child. I would watch it more as an
example of this is inappropriate behavior, you don’t go out and do this. You don’t just walk up to someone and start
beating the crap out the them. And like
you don’t this in the backyard when there is no one around, with your friends
or anything. I don’t know, I would say
in some instances yes, I could see how it would be good versus evil, like if
you were taking the good guy versus someone like the undertaker, who is
typically portrayed as the bad person.
But then again you can also say Star Wars is the same thing. I mean I was raised on Star Wars, I watched
Star Wars more when I was little, growing up, than I did wrestling.
R: Another theory states
that girls are socialized to control their hostility and to ‘act like
ladies.’ Wrestling acts as a kind of
catharsis, allowing them to vent their frustration and their aggressive
feelings. What do you think about this
theory?
D: Once again yes and
no. I can go out and vent my
frustrations and my feelings, but taking a stick to a tree and beating the crap
out of it, that would make me feel a little better, the tree might be a little
disgruntled. But, I don’t see it from
my experience, as a way for females to vent their frustrations. I think females have a perfectly adequate
way of venting their frustrations face to face rather than watching wrestling
and saying, ‘Yeah this is awesome, I want to go do that.’
R: Other observers have
noted the sexual representations inherent in various wrestling holds. Guessing that women spectators are
middle-aged and therefore, were introduced to sex in a period before... sex
became play, there observers have speculated that the woman spectator of
wrestling experiences vicarious gratification from the pain inflicted by one
(male) wrestler upon the other (male) in the sexually suggestive position. It is obvious from the kind of sentiments
expressed by many of the women in the heat of a match that their psyches are
responding to something besides the purely dramatic aspects of wrestling. ‘Lookit that hunk of man!’ is a common
cry. ‘What a build! How would ya like
to date that one. C’mon, Superman, bust him one for me.’ What are your takes on this theory?
D: On that one yes, I would
defiantly agree with it. Like cause I
have seen, when I have been in a group or even myself, I would say that
defiantly is a yes. Like I think
somewhere deep down in your psyche that there is something that there is that
thin line between pain and pleasure and that occasionally when your watching
it, its and especially when its someone you like or one of your characters that
you like. Then yes, I would say that to
that one.
R: Another theory says that
it is not necessarily the sexual appeal of the good-looking wrestling hero that
attracts women to the sport. Many of
the less attractive wrestlers receive fan letters from women and are mobbed by
women at arenas. At least one writer
believed this to be due to women’s comparing the ugly stereotype with their
husbands or male friends. The familiar
male would appear relatively more desirable.
What do you think about this one?
D: I think it depends on the
female and what her particular body type, facial features, hair aspects, which
she likes, if that is the kind of person that she enjoys, then yes. But if she likes the Hollywood look then
that is the one she is going to like more.
I think it totally depends on the women who is looking at which body
type she likes or prefers over the other one.
Big and buff versus Leonardo DiCaprio, scrawny and 12ish.
Participant
E
Researcher:
What is your age?
Participant
E: 20
R:
Where are you from?
E:
Arlington Heights, Illinois
R:
What is your major?
E:
Speech Communications major
R:
Do you watch Professional Wrestling?
E: Yes.
R:
How often do you watch?
E:
Usually about once a week.
R:
Do you watch WWF, WCW, ECW, or a combination?
E:
WWF.
R:
At what age did you start watching professional wrestling?
E: I started at about five,
but then I didn’t watch for a while, and then I recently started watching it
again about 6 months ago.
R: Do/did your parents
and/or siblings watch professional wrestling?
E: Actually, I started
watching it with my grandmother.
R: What do you think
motivates you to watch professional wrestling?
E: Um, I have two or three
things. The first one is, like I watch Raw which is on Monday nights and I
completely do homework and Raw is on at 9:00 p.m., and if you want to watch
something that seriously does not make you think at all, that is the thing to
watch. It makes me laugh out loud. I mean it is so hard to find a good comic on
tv or a good sitcom. I know by the end
of the show I will be in stitches. So
that is typically what gets me going there.
I also find it throughly interesting, especially as a communication
major, like to watch it, it is basically a male soap opera. And they pick on us with our Guiding Lights
and our General Hospital and for all practical purposes you really break it
down, that is what wrestling is for guys.
Who’s girl is going to come out with who today, who’s gonna kick who’s
butt today. You know it is a soap
opera, it is funny to watch to analyze how men must think of our soap
operas. And I also watch it because of
my boyfriend, he adores it. I must
admit it we do have some funny conversations, and he thinks that it is pretty
cool that I watch it and can understand it.
I will admit that some of my motivation to watch it, is because of him.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the same gender, if so how many?
E: Sometimes my roommate or
my friend down the hall, but only on rare occasions do I watch it with other
people.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the opposite gender, if so how many?
E: Um, Sometimes on the
weekends when they replay them, and I will be over at Notre Dame and I will
watch it. But not usually doing the
week do I watch it with guys.
R:
Do you ever reenact/recreate parts of the show?
E: Not actual wrestling
moves, I leave that up to the guys, they do it all the time. Me sometimes I pick up some of the dialog
and I will say something to my friends.
R:
What do you get out of watching professional wrestling?
E: Basically what I said
before for what motivates me to watch.
I get the laughs out of it and it is just something that I really don’t
have to have deep thoughts about. I get
the entertainment value out of watching wrestling.
R: Do you have a favorite
professional wrestler, and why do you identify with them?
E: I have some that I find
more funny that the others, but I don’t have paraphernalia from them. I mean,
Kurt Angle is really funny and he makes me laugh every time. I really like, my
favorite part of the show is when they are not wrestling, but when they are
having the dialog with the characters, because it is the worst acting in the
world and it just makes me laugh out loud.
I really don’t identify with them, it is just a comic relief.
R: Do you use any
professional wrestling language in your daily life?
E: I think recently I
started referring when my friends get into fights, I refer it to ‘laying the
Smackdown.’ But that is about it.
R:
Have you ever attended a live professional wrestling event?
E: Never.
R: What is your take on the
‘real’ versus ‘fake’ issue of professional wrestling?
E: I know it is fake, and I
think most everyone else out there knows it is fake. And I think it is fun because it is fake. It doesn’t bother me. I am not so wrapped up in it, that I am hurt
by the fact that they aren’t real people.
I think because it is fake it is safer.
If it was almost too realist, you might start getting into legal issues
by people doing things that they shouldn’t be doing.
R: What do you think are the
reasons why professional wrestling is appealing to its female viewers?
E: I know at least for myself
and my friends that watch we started watching it again because our
boyfriends. Because it is so popular
among 20-something guys and they think it is funny and start reenacting it. We are their girlfriends so and we are like
sure we will watch it, and then we get so wrapped up in the plot. Like I said, it is a male soap opera. I think that there is also a certain kind of
violence to it that we don’t normal express in the female soap opera and other
tv shows we watch. I watch Felicity all
the time, but there is not a lot of ‘Smackdown’ going down on Felicity. So sometimes you want a little bit of
violence. Sometimes you want to get
really mad. It kind of lets you live
out that whole naughty girl thing.
R: What do you think about
the way women are portrayed in professional wrestling?
E: It is obvious to say that
they are sex objects. And that they are
basically at the mercy of their guys.
When I watch though, I know it is so fake, it does not matter to me. It is a professional life they have for
crying out loud. These women chose to
do this because they want to, they are not sold into doing it. I don’t feel that it is degrading to
women. It ads to the whole wrestling
experience. If you look at a regular
soap opera, they same things are going on.
R:
How do you think women should be portrayed?
E: You know. Since wrestling is a male dominated sport
and the viewers are so highly male. If
that is how they are going to be portrayed in order to make the money, which it
is all about, who am I to tell them differently. So, I don’t think they should come out and be all like, ‘I am
gonna be the pro.’ I mean with the
women’s title when they have the women fight.
I mean obviously that is two women out there and they are like ‘we can
do this’ and ‘we can do just what they can.’
So I think in that respect I don’t think that is a bad thing.
R: If you could change
anything about professional wrestling, what would you change and why?
E: I really don’t
understand, I find it when they bring out all the tables and chairs and hit
each other, that just blows my mind, I have no idea why that appeals to
them. It was maybe fun the first time,
but you see them go through about eight tables, it is nothing funny
anymore. So, I would say they need some
new tricks, gimmicks because the tables and chairs just don’t do it for
me. Maybe different sets or
stages. We as women I think are visual
people and with the same stage settings all the time, it gets a little old.
R: What do you think are the
differences between professional wrestling’s attractiveness toward it’s male
viewers and it’s female viewers?
E: Men are attracted by the
sheer kind of violence of it. I mean
men like that in the movies they like action movies, not saying that women
don’t, but in general men are totally ‘it’s ok yeah lets go beat their
friends.’ But come on, the environment
that we are in at college, I don’t think the rectors at Notre Dame are going to
appreciate if they are going to be jumping people down the hall. I just think it is a release for them. But at the same time they know it is fake
and they know tat it is not really happening.
Men won’t admit it but they also I think like the whole saga and story
line stuff as well. And as for the
women, I have talked to some of my friends and one of the things that we watch
it for is the whole saga story lines in between the actual wrestling. I think we are still associating it with
other dramas on television. We want the
storyline and guys want the action.
R: I am going to read a few
of the theories concerning the popularity of wrestling as a spectator sport
among women, what do you think about these theories? OK, here is the first one.
One theory says that women are the ‘traditional custodians of morality,’
and are especially attracted to the morality play between the forces of good
and evil.
E: Well that is
interesting. We always want to see the
good prevail. Except that on occasion that if the character, is of the certain
negative type the antagonist character types, that are sort of more well
written. That I am not so sure that
good always wins or they choose the good person to win. We are more apt to look at it like, ‘oh that
character is not written as well as that character.’ I would say that that is an interesting theory that we want to
see the good prevail. They are fighting
anyway, like is there an ultimate good here?
R: Another theory states
that girls are socialized to control their hostility and to ‘act like
ladies.’ Wrestling acts as a kind of
catharsis, allowing them to vent their frustration and their aggressive
feelings. What do you think about this
theory?
E: Yeah, I would say that is
pretty on target. I don’t want to pound on anybody and I don’t want to get into
a ring and put a chair in some ones back.
But you know, every once in a while I feel like that would be something
we are not suppose to be watching so buy turning it on it is like taking a step
and just saying, ‘So there, I am watching it anyway.’ So yes, I would say that is pretty on target with that idea.
R: Other observers have
noted the sexual representations inherent in various wrestling holds. Guessing that women spectators are
middle-aged and therefore, were introduced to sex in a period before... sex
became play, there observers have speculated that the woman spectator of
wrestling experiences vicarious gratification from the pain inflicted by one
(male) wrestler upon the other (male) in the sexually suggestive position. It is obvious from the kind of sentiments
expressed by many of the women in the heat of a match that their psyches are
responding to something besides the purely dramatic aspects of wrestling.
‘Lookit that hunk of man!’ is a common cry.
‘What a build! How would ya like to date that one. C’mon, Superman, bust
him one for me.’ What are your takes on
this theory?
E: You know I look at
wrestlers and there is not one thing about them that remotely turns me on. Like, I am not big on big muscles and they
look all sweaty and eewww. But I can
see where women might have that whole, there are a lot of women who really want
a bigger stronger man, this protective nature thing. If they win the match, you know in the ring, he is going to be a
champion, and what women wouldn’t want a champion, whether it be in the
business world or in the wrestling ring.
So, I can see where that notion would fit there. I can’t say that version is what pops into
my mind when I watch it, but I can see a lot of women out there where that
would be in the back of their psyche.
R: Another theory says that
it is not necessarily the sexual appeal of the good-looking wrestling hero that
attracts women to the sport. Many of
the less attractive wrestlers receive fan letters from women and are mobbed by
women at arenas. At least one writer
believed this to be due to women’s comparing the ugly stereotype with their
husbands or male friends. The familiar
male would appear relatively more desirable.
What do you think about this one?
E: I go for more of the
familiar look whether it be a wrestler or whether it be some kind of
television, just a general show. I have
never been one for the playboy look or something that looks unattainable. So, women finding sort of ‘oh he has dark
hair like my husband.’ Also I think it
is kind of an underdog type thing.
Women generally go for an underdog attitude, whether it be a sporting
event or whatever. I can see where
women want to go for that naturalist sort of realism thing.
Participant
F
Researcher:
What is your age?
Participant
F: 20
R:
Where are you from?
F:
Traverse City, Michigan
R:
What is your major?
F:
Undecided
R:
Do you watch Professional Wrestling?
F:
yes
R:
How often do you watch?
F:
Not as much as I do at home, but usually once or twice a week.
R:
Do you watch WWF, WCW, ECW, or a combination?
F:
WWF
R:
At what age did you start watching professional wrestling?
F:
18
R: Do/did your parents
and/or siblings watch professional wrestling?
F: Yeah, my dad sometimes
watches it
R: What do you think motivates
you to watch professional wrestling?
F: My friends motivate me to
watch, I am very much one of the guys at home, so watching wrestling is just
another way of being with them.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the same gender, if so how many?
F: There might be one other
girl friend that watches with us, but only on occasion.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the opposite gender, if so how many?
F:
Usually there is about 5 or 6 guys.
R:
Do you ever reenact/recreate parts of the show?
F: Yeah we actually have
done Smackdown before. Everyone
including myself partake in the theatrics.
We don’t take on character names, but we just do holds or just mess
around.
R:
What do you get out of watching professional wrestling?
F: Wrestling is just one of
those things that you just don’t really have to think about, you know it is
just purely entertainment.
R: Do you have a favorite
professional wrestler, and why do you identify with them?
F: Well when we watch it
there is this one Wrestler name Lita.
That is one of my nicknames at home, because I watch it. So I guess I identify with her in that way.
R: Do you use any
professional wrestling language in your daily life?
F: Um, When I am on instant
messenger with my friends I do. My
friends screen name is the Rock so I always make comments to him.
R:
Have you ever attended a live professional wrestling event?
F: I don’t think so, that is
crossing the line for me.
R: What is your take on the
‘real’ versus ‘fake’ issue of professional wrestling?
F: I mean, it is real
because there is the risk of getting injured, but it is fake because of the
fact that it is choreographed. They
know how the moves are going to go, how to get the crowd to get excited, what
props they are going to use. It is very
theatrical.
R: What do you think are the
reasons why professional wrestling is appealing to its female viewers?
F: Well for a lot of girls
that I know it is because it is an easy way to get boys to notice you. Like if you can rattle off the names of
wrestlers and stuff. I mean that is one
of the main things.
R: What do you think about
the way women are portrayed in professional wrestling?
F: It is degrading to one
sense, I mean their outfits are very suggestive and they are very much
silicon. But I mean on the other hand
if you look at it from they’re woman of obvious strength who are competing with
men on the same level, it might over rule it for some, like Chyna.
R:
How do you think women should be portrayed?
F: I don’t know, because
with it being such a physical sport, they have to muscular and have to be
athletic, but since it is also entertainment they also have to be sexual and
have to be appealing. So I don’t know
you can’t be physically engaging and dominating others with out having sexual
connotations about it.
R: If you could change
anything about professional wrestling, what would you change and why?
F: Well my mom does
preschool and works at an elementary school
and she gets a lot of kids that watch it and think that it is real and
see the wrestlers beating up on people so they think that it is ok to do that
on the play ground. So I think they
should emphasize that it is not real and not to try the stuff they do at home.
R: What do you think are the
differences between professional wrestling’s attractiveness toward it’s male
viewers and it’s female viewers?
F: I think on one sense it
is primal for them it is getting up and fighting and finding out who is
stronger and being very flamboyant. For
females I think we know that it is not real and something we can watch to make
us laugh. We can also get into the
think intricate plot while the guys are into the action.
R: I am going to read a few
of the theories concerning the popularity of wrestling as a spectator sport
among women, what do you think about these theories? OK, here is the first one.
One theory says that women are the ‘traditional custodians of morality,’
and are especially attracted to the morality play between the forces of good
and evil.
F: I think that is going a
little deeper. I mean at least not when
I watch it I’m not like who are the forces of good and who are the forces of
evil. I mean there are defiantly are
but I think everyone of the wrestlers has both sides to them. So every viewer might see the wrestlers
differently, like one viewer might see a wrestlers good side and someone else
would see his bad side.
R: Another theory states
that girls are socialized to control their hostility and to ‘act like
ladies.’ Wrestling acts as a kind of
catharsis, allowing them to vent their frustration and their aggressive
feelings. What do you think about this
theory?
F: I agree with that one a
little bit. Like when we play it out we
sometimes, it will go that step further and we will dominate. Where as usual it wont go over just pushing
your man down on the couch and pinning him down. It is a way to vent that on kind of a conscious level.
R: Other observers have
noted the sexual representations inherent in various wrestling holds. Guessing that women spectators are
middle-aged and therefore, were introduced to sex in a period before... sex
became play, there observers have speculated that the woman spectator of
wrestling experiences vicarious gratification from the pain inflicted by one
(male) wrestler upon the other (male) in the sexually suggestive position. It is obvious from the kind of sentiments
expressed by many of the women in the heat of a match that their psyches are
responding to something besides the purely dramatic aspects of wrestling. ‘Lookit that hunk of man!’ is a common
cry. ‘What a build! How would ya like
to date that one. C’mon, Superman, bust him one for me.’ What are your takes on this theory?
F: I would think so a
little. Because some wrestlers can be
very aggressive and attractive. There
are a lot of sexual tones to it, where I guess 30 years ago you wouldn’t be
able to watch action like this and be able to get excited about this stuff and
go ‘woo’ and get into it and go screaming, you know, get into a frenzy when
watch it. Where as now you can.
R: Another theory says that
it is not necessarily the sexual appeal of the good-looking wrestling hero that
attracts women to the sport. Many of
the less attractive wrestlers receive fan letters from women and are mobbed by women
at arenas. At least one writer believed
this to be due to women’s comparing the ugly stereotype with their husbands or
male friends. The familiar male would
appear relatively more desirable. What
do you think about this one?
F: Oh yeah, defiantly I
think so. I mean you will always go after
the one that is my attainable. The less
attractive one you might have a chance with and the more likely you might know
someone that is like them rather than someone with the Hollywood look.
Participant
G
Researcher:
What is your age?
Participant
G:18
R:
Where are you from?
G:
South Bend, Indiana
R:
What is your major?
G:
Nursing
R:
Do you watch Professional Wrestling?
G:
Yes, I do.
R:
How often do you watch?
G:
I’d say at least twice every two weeks
R:
Do you watch WWF, WCW, ECW, or a combination?
G:
WWF, only.
R:
At what age did you start watching professional wrestling?
G: I was in elementary
school, but there was a gap between sixth grade and junior year in high school,
where I didn’t watch it, but I started watching it again when I got into my junior
year.
R: Do/did your parents
and/or siblings watch professional wrestling?
G: Yeah, everyone in my
family did.
R: What do you think
motivates you to watch professional wrestling?
G: Well in the beginning in
elementary school I started watching it because I was a tomboy. Me and my brother did everything together
from playing football to climbing trees together to watching wrestling
together. So it was like the cool thing
to do. Now I watch it pretty much for
the Rock. Cause he is fine. It is like different
things, like now, you understand the drama in the middle of it when you get
older. It is more a soap opera, you
are following a story.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the same gender, if so how many?
G: No, actually usually it
is with my brother. But sometimes if
someone is walking down the hall and I am watching it, they might stop in, so
it would be only one other person besides me.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the opposite gender, if so how many?
G:
One, usually.
R:
Do you ever reenact/recreate parts of the show?
G: Yes, well it is more or
less the catch phrases for each of the wrestlers. Like the Rock’s ‘Can you smell what the Rock is cookin.’
R:
What do you get out of watching professional wrestling?
G: It is funny. Most of it is pure comedy. I mean really, that is probably the main
thing. The other would be like what I
said earlier, the Rock.
R: Do you have a favorite
professional wrestler, and why do you identify with them?
G: Well, the Rock. Because, you know what attracted me to him
was the fact that he wasn’t just white, he is a mix of races. You rarely see that in the WWF. He gets all the attention, he is the main
man. I think that is cool. He is different than any of the other
wrestlers. He has his own style and his
own way of talking, his own way dressing.
He is just different. I think
that is what makes him stand out.
R: Do you use any
professional wrestling language in your daily life?
G: I would say no, not in my
daily life. Its like if I was joking
around with somebody, I might say something.
R:
Have you ever attended a live professional wrestling event?
G: No, I want to though.
R: What is your take on the
‘real’ versus ‘fake’ issue of professional wrestling?
G: It’s fake, I mean
everyone knows it, if you don’t too bad.
The fact is that it is a real sport and they do do real activity that
does take real physical exertion out of you.
And they have to train for all the physical activity that they do. I do realize that some of them do really get
hurt, so that is the real part of the wrestling as far as the scenarios and the
marriages, that is all fake, it is just part of the industry.
R: What do you think are the
reasons why professional wrestling is appealing to its female viewers?
G: Well, the Rock... ha
ha... I can’t lie, the man has it going on.
I mean, I’d say the body of the male wrestler attracts females a
lot. Chyna is also really cool for the
females. She is a good representative,
at the same time she has the glamor and the strength.
R: What do you think about
the way women are portrayed in professional wrestling?
G: You got the two different
sides. You got the Chyna and there is
the Cat. Chyna represents the whole
wrestler look and powerful and then there is Terri she is like slut city. It is
just two total different things.
R:
How do you think women should be portrayed?
G: In every respectful way
possible. I mean I believe that a woman
was created in God’s image as much as man was.
I feel like your body is the temple of God. So, you should always keep respect every way possible. I realize that the WWF, you know, they dress
pretty skanky. But when it comes down
to it, you see these women doing interviews on talk shows and stuff and they
will be covered up. I mean they still
hold their own in a respectful way in the real world.
R: If you could change
anything about professional wrestling, what would you change and why?
G: I would take out the way
the women dress. I mean because it is
distracting. But hey that is the WWF,
they pull in huge amounts of money and huge amounts of fans. That is what the public wants but I
defiantly don’t like it.
R: What do you think are the
differences between professional wrestling’s attractiveness toward it’s male
viewers and it’s female viewers?
G: I want to touch on the
similarities first. The similarity
would be like the men tuning in to see the girls and the women tuning in to see
the guys, to see how hot they are and whatever. But on the difference side, the guys look at it like, ‘Oh, did
you see that move, did you see the way he hit him.’ But on the other had, girls look at it like, ‘I can’t believe he
cheated on Stephanie and I can’t believe he did that.’ It is more of the drama type of deal.
R: I am going to read a few
of the theories concerning the popularity of wrestling as a spectator sport
among women, what do you think about these theories? OK, here is the first one.
One theory says that women are the ‘traditional custodians of morality,’
and are especially attracted to the morality play between the forces of good
and evil.
G: That is interesting
actually. I see this in wrestling too,
women are kind of devious, they are sneaky.
People will sometimes go as far as saying that Eve took the apple. I don’t know, I have never really thought
about it that way before. I do see that
in myself a lot, like Triple H is bad, the Rock is good. So I would say yeah, I agree with it to a certain
degree. I just never thought about it
in that way.
R: Another theory states
that girls are socialized to control their hostility and to ‘act like
ladies.’ Wrestling acts as a kind of
catharsis, allowing them to vent their frustration and their aggressive
feelings. What do you think about this
theory?
G: Totally, totally true. I mean, it has always been said buy mothers
and grandmothers, ‘Be a lady, don’t kick, don’t hit, don’t fight, be lady
like.’ You can just get it all out when
you watch.
R: Other observers have
noted the sexual representations inherent in various wrestling holds. Guessing that women spectators are
middle-aged and therefore, were introduced to sex in a period before... sex
became play, there observers have speculated that the woman spectator of
wrestling experiences vicarious gratification from the pain inflicted by one
(male) wrestler upon the other (male) in the sexually suggestive position. It is obvious from the kind of sentiments
expressed by many of the women in the heat of a match that their psyches are responding
to something besides the purely dramatic aspects of wrestling. ‘Lookit that hunk of man!’ is a common
cry. ‘What a build! How would ya like
to date that one. C’mon, Superman, bust him one for me.’ What are your takes on this theory?
G: Wow, that was weird. I don’t know maybe in your subconscious,
that is the only thing I could say. If
anything it is totally the opposite.
Like ew, he shouldn’t be holding him that way, let him go. But hey, in your subconscious, I think that
is gross. Not consciously would I think
of it in that way.
R: Another theory says that
it is not necessarily the sexual appeal of the good-looking wrestling hero that
attracts women to the sport. Many of
the less attractive wrestlers receive fan letters from women and are mobbed by
women at arenas. At least one writer
believed this to be due to women’s comparing the ugly stereotype with their
husbands or male friends. The familiar
male would appear relatively more desirable.
What do you think about this one?
G: I understand that, but I
don’t agree with it. It is like when it
comes to tv and entertainment stuff it is the cute, hot body guy that gets the
attention. I mean, there is always a
minority, and there is always an exception.
And that is what they touched on there.
Women are attracted to the less popular, but that is a small percentage,
I’d say. Most of the girls like the
Rock and I am one of them. So I would
say I understand what they are saying and it is most likely true, but it is not
what I go for.
Participant
H
Researcher:
What is your age?
Participant
H: 18
R:
Where are you from?
H:
Buchanan, Michigan
R:
What is your major?
H:
Double major in psychology and art.
R:
Do you watch Professional Wrestling?
H:
Yes.
R:
How often do you watch?
H: I try to watch all of the
shows, but sometimes only make it to Monday night Raw
R:
Do you watch WWF, WCW, ECW, or a combination?
H:
Just WWF.
R:
At what age did you start watching professional wrestling?
H:
17.
R: Do/did your parents
and/or siblings watch professional wrestling?
H: Yes, my dad and brother.
R: What do you think
motivates you to watch professional wrestling?
H: I like the Rock.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the same gender, if so how many?
H: No I watch with my dad.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the opposite gender, if so how many?
H:
Yes. My dad
R:
Do you ever reenact/recreate parts of the show?
H:
No.
R:
What do you get out of watching professional wrestling?
H: Entertainment value.
R: Do you have a favorite
professional wrestler, and why do you identify with them?
H: I like the Rock. I like him because, outside the ring he is
just a really good guy.
R: Do you use any
professional wrestling language in your daily life?
H:
Not everyday, but sometimes.
R:
Have you ever attended a live professional wrestling event?
H: No. I would love to
though.
R: What is your take on the
‘real’ versus ‘fake’ issue of professional wrestling?
H: I think it is fake. They have biographies, and if you watch it,
they are all friends with the people that they are fighting with.
R: What do you think are the
reasons why professional wrestling is appealing to its female viewers?
H: To watch the guys. To see them in there little shorts.
R: What do you think about
the way women are portrayed in professional wrestling?
H: I don’t like the way they
are portrayed. But the woman that
participate, I think, set themselves up for that.
R:
How do you think women should be portrayed?
H: Well, I don’t think that
they should be portrayed as hoes, like with the Godfather’s hoe train. But, I really, for the entertainment I don’t
think there is any other way to portray them, to make it interesting.
R: If you could change
anything about professional wrestling, what would you change and why?
H: I don’t think I would
change anything. I like it the way it
is.
R: What do you think are the
differences between professional wrestling’s attractiveness toward it’s male
viewers and it’s female viewers?
H: I think a lot of guys
watch it to see the girls come out in their little outfits. I know a lot of the time they have striping
contests. I think they get
entertainment out of that. I think the
women get entertainment out of watching the guy wrestler bodies.
R: I am going to read a few
of the theories concerning the popularity of wrestling as a spectator sport
among women, what do you think about these theories? OK, here is the first one.
One theory says that women are the ‘traditional custodians of morality,’
and are especially attracted to the morality play between the forces of good
and evil.
H: I really don’t look at it
like that. I just see it as
entertainment. I really don’t get into
it like that.
R: Another theory states
that girls are socialized to control their hostility and to ‘act like
ladies.’ Wrestling acts as a kind of
catharsis, allowing them to vent their frustration and their aggressive
feelings. What do you think about this
theory?
H: I agree with that a
little. I don’t agree with the part
that says women are trained. I don’t
think in society they are trained, but I do see where, I do see myself yelling
at the tv and getting into it. I agree
with that part of it, it does let out frustrations.
R: Other observers have
noted the sexual representations inherent in various wrestling holds. Guessing that women spectators are
middle-aged and therefore, were introduced to sex in a period before... sex
became play, there observers have speculated that the woman spectator of
wrestling experiences vicarious gratification from the pain inflicted by one
(male) wrestler upon the other (male) in the sexually suggestive position. It is obvious from the kind of sentiments
expressed by many of the women in the heat of a match that their psyches are
responding to something besides the purely dramatic aspects of wrestling. ‘Lookit that hunk of man!’ is a common
cry. ‘What a build! How would ya like
to date that one. C’mon, Superman, bust him one for me.’ What are your takes on this theory?
H: I agree with that. Because I know that is a lot of the reasons
why I watch it. I really like the Rock
and the muscles and all that, makes me want to watch it more.
R: Another theory says that
it is not necessarily the sexual appeal of the good-looking wrestling hero that
attracts women to the sport. Many of
the less attractive wrestlers receive fan letters from women and are mobbed by
women at arenas. At least one writer
believed this to be due to women’s comparing the ugly stereotype with their
husbands or male friends. The familiar
male would appear relatively more desirable.
What do you think about this one?
H: Yeah, I kind of agree
with that. I mean I like Mankind, and
he isn’t the most attractive guy, but he is really funny.
Participant
I
Researcher:
What is your age?
Participant
I: 21
R:
Where are you from?
I:
South Bend, Indiana
R:
What is your major?
I:
English Literature, French Literature and Secondary Education.
R:
Do you watch Professional Wrestling?
I:
Yes.
R:
How often do you watch?
I:
Usually once a week.
R:
Do you watch WWF, WCW, ECW, or a combination?
I:
WWF.
R:
At what age did you start watching professional wrestling?
I:
20
R: Do/did your parents
and/or siblings watch professional wrestling?
I: No.
R: What do you think
motivates you to watch professional wrestling?
I: The storylines mainly.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the same gender, if so how many?
I: No, not usually.
R: Do you watch with other
people of the opposite gender, if so how many?
I:
Yes, and one.
R:
Do you ever reenact/recreate parts of the show?
I:
Nope.
R:
What do you get out of watching professional wrestling?
I: Pretty much for the
entertainment value.
R: Do you have a favorite
professional wrestler, and why do you identify with them?
I: Well my favorite is Edge
and Christian. Just because they are so
funny. And they are hot.
R: Do you use any
professional wrestling language in your daily life?
I:
Yeah, Like ‘laying the Smackdown.’
R:
Have you ever attended a live professional wrestling event?
I: No.
R: What is your take on the
‘real’ versus ‘fake’ issue of professional wrestling?
I: That it is pretty much
fake, basically. But people might actually get hurt.
R: What do you think are the
reasons why professional wrestling is appealing to its female viewers?
I: Because it is more like a
soap opera than watching other shows.
R: What do you think about
the way women are portrayed in professional wrestling?
I: I think it is probably
some what negative most of the time.
But like some women just dress fine.
I don’t think it is good how they are sometimes portrayed.
R:
How do you think women should be portrayed?
I: I think that in that
context that’s they way they should be because, that is what you want from them
right then.
R: If you could change
anything about professional wrestling, what would you change and why?
I: Um, I really don’t think
I would change anything. I like it the
way it is.
R: What do you think are the
differences between professional wrestling’s attractiveness toward it’s male
viewers and it’s female viewers?
I: I think men watch it for
the fighting and things like that. I
watch it for the storylines. I think
guys also watch it for the girls on their and the same could be said for the
women watching for the guys.
R: I am going to read a few
of the theories concerning the popularity of wrestling as a spectator sport
among women, what do you think about these theories? OK, here is the first one.
One theory says that women are the ‘traditional custodians of morality,’
and are especially attracted to the morality play between the forces of good
and evil.
I: That could be, but I
really don’t see it like that. Everyone
is slightly good and slightly bad.
R: Another theory states
that girls are socialized to control their hostility and to ‘act like
ladies.’ Wrestling acts as a kind of
catharsis, allowing them to vent their frustration and their aggressive
feelings. What do you think about this
theory?
I: Yeah a little, I can see
how women would do that. But not apply
to me as much.
R: Other observers have
noted the sexual representations inherent in various wrestling holds. Guessing that women spectators are
middle-aged and therefore, were introduced to sex in a period before... sex
became play, there observers have speculated that the woman spectator of
wrestling experiences vicarious gratification from the pain inflicted by one
(male) wrestler upon the other (male) in the sexually suggestive position. It is obvious from the kind of sentiments
expressed by many of the women in the heat of a match that their psyches are
responding to something besides the purely dramatic aspects of wrestling. ‘Lookit that hunk of man!’ is a common
cry. ‘What a build! How would ya like
to date that one. C’mon, Superman, bust him one for me.’ What are your takes on this theory?
I: I’d have to say that this
one out of the ones read so far is the most out there. We are obviously not middle aged. And sex has always been out there for us. So
I really don’t believe that one to be true.
R: Another theory says that
it is not necessarily the sexual appeal of the good-looking wrestling hero that
attracts women to the sport. Many of
the less attractive wrestlers receive fan letters from women and are mobbed by
women at arenas. At least one writer
believed this to be due to women’s comparing the ugly stereotype with their
husbands or male friends. The familiar
male would appear relatively more desirable.
What do you think about this one?
I: I don’t think that sounds
plausible. I can’t see that to be true.
The Variable List
|
Variable |
Description |
Definition |
|
Influences |
male, female |
male: dad, brother, boyfriend,
guy friends female: mom, sister, grandmother,
girl friends |
|
Motivators |
soap
opera storylines, drama, guys |
soap
opera storylines:
intriguing conversations between friends and enemies drama: the dramatic effects of
the shows plot guys: guy friends, male
wrestlers, boyfriends |
|
What
one gets out
of watching |
entertainment, laughs, mindless
fun, relaxing |
entertainment: the value of entertaining
oneself for a period of time laughs: hilarious, good times mindless
fun: no
deep thought process to watch, it is something to do and not think relaxing: escape from reality |
|
Reenact/ Recreation |
catch
phrases, hand
gestures, wrestling
moves or holds |
catch
phrases:
“Can you smell what the Rock is cookin”, “Laying the Smackdown” hand
gestures:
the people’s elbow wrestling
moves or holds:
piledriver, spear, body slam, headlock |
|
Appeal
to Female Viewers |
body
type, soap
opera storylines, breaks
mold |
body
type:
big, buff, muscular bodies soap
opera storylines:
intriguing conversations between friends and enemies breaks
mold:
breaking feminine molds, not acting like ladies |
|
Appeal
to Male Viewers |
aggression, action, wrestling moves |
aggression: violent acts towards
others action: death defying tricks, not
stop adventure wrestling
moves:
piledriver, spear, body slam, headlock |